An Economy With Zero Human Beings In It?

How much of the internet and digital environment many now live their lives entirely engulfed in is completely fake? A disturbing report in New York Magazine lays out some key facts, beginning with the following astounding trend:

For a period of time in 2013, the Times reported this year, a full half of YouTube traffic was “bots masquerading as people,” a portion so high that employees feared an inflection point after which YouTube’s systems for detecting fraudulent traffic would begin to regard bot traffic as real and human traffic as fake. They called this hypothetical event “the Inversion.”

Some of the methods and data revealing just how we arrived at a largely “fake internet” were revealed by alarming Justice Department findings based on unsealed indictments against eight people involved in what’s widely considered among the largest digital ad-fraud operations ever uncovered, as the accused fleeced advertisers to the tune of $36 million.

NY Mag explains of their methods, which are indicative of what’s happening more broadly:

The two schemes at issue in the case, dubbed Methbot and 3ve by the security researchers who found them, faked both. Hucksters infected 1.7 million computers with malware that remotely directed traffic to “spoofed” websites — “empty websites designed for bot traffic” that served up a video ad purchased from one of the internet’s vast programmatic ad-exchanges, but that were designed, according to the indictments, “to fool advertisers into thinking that an impression of their ad was served on a premium publisher site,” like that of Vogue or The Economist.

This resulted in an army of bots that could imitate humans producing “faked clicks, mouse movements, and social network login information to masquerade as engaged human consumers” as one exhaustive study demonstrated.

Studies compiled over past years suggest a general trend, notes NY Mag, that less than 60 percent off all web traffic is human, with some researchers finding a “healthy majority” of this to be bots.

Getting easier to imagine an economy with zero human beings in it. https://t.co/J2Qyab7TKj

— Matt Pearce 🦅 (@mattdpearce) December 27, 2018

There are also perhaps simpler, or less technologically sophisticated means employed to generate fake clicks namely the “click farm” phenomena.

The report finds, for example, that a YouTube creator wishing to up their clicks and subscribers, and thereby increase ad revenue, can hire a click farm to produce 5,000 video views for as little as $15.

I never tire of looking at videos of Chinese click farms. It’s just so surreal to see hundreds of phones playing the same video for the purposes of fake engagment. pic.twitter.com/bHAGLqRqVb

— Matthew Brennan (@mbrennanchina) December 10, 2018

The NY Mag report explains the following:

And maybe we shouldn’t even assume that the people are real. Over at YouTube, the business of buying and selling video views is “flourishing,” as the Times reminded readers with a lengthy investigation in August. The company says only “a tiny fraction” of its traffic is fake, but fake subscribers are enough of a problem that the site undertook a purge of “spam accounts” in mid-December. These days, the Times found, you can buy 5,000 YouTube views — 30 seconds of a video counts as a view — for as low as $15; oftentimes, customers are led to believe that the views they purchase come from real people. More likely, they come from bots. On some platforms, video views and app downloads can be forged in lucrative industrial counterfeiting operations. If you want a picture of what the Inversion looks like, find a video of a “click farm”: hundreds of individual smartphones, arranged in rows on shelves or racks in professional-looking offices, each watching the same video or downloading the same app.

Could we indeed be headed for as LA Times journalist Matt Pearce put it an economy with zero human beings in it?

An Economy With Zero Human Beings In It? <body> <h1> Array ( [0] => zn economy with zero human beings in it? [1] => sn economy with zero human beings in it? [2] => wn economy with zero human beings in it? [3] => qn economy with zero human beings in it? [4] => ab economy with zero human beings in it? [5] => am economy with zero human beings in it? [6] => aj economy with zero human beings in it? [7] => ah economy with zero human beings in it? [8] => an wconomy with zero human beings in it? [9] => an sconomy with zero human beings in it? [10] => an dconomy with zero human beings in it? [11] => an rconomy with zero human beings in it? [12] => an 4conomy with zero human beings in it? [13] => an 3conomy with zero human beings in it? [14] => an exonomy with zero human beings in it? [15] => an evonomy with zero human beings in it? [16] => an efonomy with zero human beings in it? [17] => an edonomy with zero human beings in it? [18] => an ecinomy with zero human beings in it? [19] => an ecknomy with zero human beings in it? [20] => an eclnomy with zero human beings in it? [21] => an ecpnomy with zero human beings in it? [22] => an ec0nomy with zero human beings in it? [23] => an ec9nomy with zero human beings in it? [24] => an ecobomy with zero human beings in it? [25] => an ecomomy with zero human beings in it? [26] => an ecojomy with zero human beings in it? [27] => an ecohomy with zero human beings in it? [28] => an econimy with zero human beings in it? [29] => an econkmy with zero human beings in it? [30] => an econlmy with zero human beings in it? [31] => an econpmy with zero human beings in it? [32] => an econ0my with zero human beings in it? [33] => an econ9my with zero human beings in it? [34] => an econony with zero human beings in it? [35] => an econoky with zero human beings in it? [36] => an econojy with zero human beings in it? [37] => an economt with zero human beings in it? [38] => an economg with zero human beings in it? [39] => an economh with zero human beings in it? [40] => an economu with zero human beings in it? [41] => an econom7 with zero human beings in it? [42] => an econom6 with zero human beings in it? [43] => an economy qith zero human beings in it? [44] => an economy aith zero human beings in it? [45] => an economy sith zero human beings in it? [46] => an economy eith zero human beings in it? [47] => an economy 3ith zero human beings in it? [48] => an economy 2ith zero human beings in it? [49] => an economy wuth zero human beings in it? [50] => an economy wjth zero human beings in it? [51] => an economy wkth zero human beings in it? [52] => an economy woth zero human beings in it? [53] => an economy w9th zero human beings in it? [54] => an economy w8th zero human beings in it? [55] => an economy wirh zero human beings in it? [56] => an economy wifh zero human beings in it? [57] => an economy wigh zero human beings in it? [58] => an economy wiyh zero human beings in it? [59] => an economy wi6h zero human beings in it? [60] => an economy wi5h zero human beings in it? [61] => an economy witg zero human beings in it? [62] => an economy witb zero human beings in it? [63] => an economy witn zero human beings in it? [64] => an economy witj zero human beings in it? [65] => an economy witu zero human beings in it? [66] => an economy wity zero human beings in it? [67] => an economy with xero human beings in it? [68] => an economy with sero human beings in it? [69] => an economy with aero human beings in it? [70] => an economy with zwro human beings in it? [71] => an economy with zsro human beings in it? [72] => an economy with zdro human beings in it? [73] => an economy with zrro human beings in it? [74] => an economy with z4ro human beings in it? [75] => an economy with z3ro human beings in it? [76] => an economy with zeeo human beings in it? [77] => an economy with zedo human beings in it? [78] => an economy with zefo human beings in it? [79] => an economy with zeto human beings in it? [80] => an economy with ze5o human beings in it? [81] => an economy with ze4o human beings in it? [82] => an economy with zeri human beings in it? [83] => an economy with zerk human beings in it? [84] => an economy with zerl human beings in it? [85] => an economy with zerp human beings in it? [86] => an economy with zer0 human beings in it? [87] => an economy with zer9 human beings in it? [88] => an economy with zero guman beings in it? [89] => an economy with zero buman beings in it? [90] => an economy with zero numan beings in it? [91] => an economy with zero juman beings in it? [92] => an economy with zero uuman beings in it? [93] => an economy with zero yuman beings in it? [94] => an economy with zero hyman beings in it? [95] => an economy with zero hhman beings in it? [96] => an economy with zero hjman beings in it? [97] => an economy with zero himan beings in it? [98] => an economy with zero h8man beings in it? [99] => an economy with zero h7man beings in it? [100] => an economy with zero hunan beings in it? [101] => an economy with zero hukan beings in it? [102] => an economy with zero hujan beings in it? [103] => an economy with zero humzn beings in it? [104] => an economy with zero humsn beings in it? [105] => an economy with zero humwn beings in it? [106] => an economy with zero humqn beings in it? [107] => an economy with zero humab beings in it? [108] => an economy with zero humam beings in it? [109] => an economy with zero humaj beings in it? [110] => an economy with zero humah beings in it? [111] => an economy with zero human veings in it? [112] => an economy with zero human neings in it? [113] => an economy with zero human heings in it? [114] => an economy with zero human geings in it? [115] => an economy with zero human bwings in it? [116] => an economy with zero human bsings in it? [117] => an economy with zero human bdings in it? [118] => an economy with zero human brings in it? [119] => an economy with zero human b4ings in it? [120] => an economy with zero human b3ings in it? [121] => an economy with zero human beungs in it? [122] => an economy with zero human bejngs in it? [123] => an economy with zero human bekngs in it? [124] => an economy with zero human beongs in it? [125] => an economy with zero human be9ngs in it? [126] => an economy with zero human be8ngs in it? [127] => an economy with zero human beibgs in it? [128] => an economy with zero human beimgs in it? [129] => an economy with zero human beijgs in it? [130] => an economy with zero human beihgs in it? [131] => an economy with zero human beinfs in it? [132] => an economy with zero human beinvs in it? [133] => an economy with zero human beinbs in it? [134] => an economy with zero human beinhs in it? [135] => an economy with zero human beinys in it? [136] => an economy with zero human beints in it? [137] => an economy with zero human beinga in it? [138] => an economy with zero human beingz in it? [139] => an economy with zero human beingx in it? [140] => an economy with zero human beingd in it? [141] => an economy with zero human beinge in it? [142] => an economy with zero human beingw in it? [143] => an economy with zero human beings un it? [144] => an economy with zero human beings jn it? [145] => an economy with zero human beings kn it? [146] => an economy with zero human beings on it? [147] => an economy with zero human beings 9n it? [148] => an economy with zero human beings 8n it? [149] => an economy with zero human beings ib it? [150] => an economy with zero human beings im it? [151] => an economy with zero human beings ij it? [152] => an economy with zero human beings ih it? [153] => an economy with zero human beings in ut? [154] => an economy with zero human beings in jt? [155] => an economy with zero human beings in kt? [156] => an economy with zero human beings in ot? [157] => an economy with zero human beings in 9t? [158] => an economy with zero human beings in 8t? [159] => an economy with zero human beings in ir? [160] => an economy with zero human beings in if? [161] => an economy with zero human beings in ig? [162] => an economy with zero human beings in iy? [163] => an economy with zero human beings in i6? [164] => an economy with zero human beings in i5? ) </h1> </body>