China Beige Book Issues Dire Fourth-Quarter Preview

By Rahul Vaidyanath of The Epoch Times

Just about every economic measure is trending down in China, and not surprisingly, deflation fears are mounting. The China Beige Book (CBB) fourth-quarter preview, released Dec. 27, reported that sales volumes, output, domestic and export orders, investment, and hiring all fell on a year-over-year and quarter-over-quarter basis.

A much-weaker 2019 appears to be in the offing for China, but it’s not solely due to trade tensions with the United States. The domestic economy was already on weak footing and the CBB argues that government support is unlikely.

The CBB is a research service that speaks to thousands of companies and bankers on the ground in China every quarter. It contends that deflation is the bigger threat compared to inflation.

“Because of China’s structural problems, deflation has very clearly emerged as the bigger threat in a slowing economy than inflation. Consumer demand has weakened, and you see that reflected in retail and services prices,” said Shehzad Qazi, CBB managing director, in an interview.

While lower prices look good for consumers, policy-makers don’t like deflation for a number of reasons. With prices falling, companies produce less, often lay off workers, and reduce investment, leading to a vicious circle of sorts. While the trade war hurts export-sensitive regions, local orders have now weakened for two straight quarters.

Hiring fell for the first time since early 2016. Worse still, the fall was concentrated in services and retail, two sectors being counted upon to pick up the slack left by manufacturing’s woes.

Also, debt—of which China has plenty—becomes more problematic under deflation, as its value adjusted for inflation rises.

And it’s an issue for central bankers, who typically target 2 percent inflation for price stability. Rate cuts to spur the economy and inflation are less effective, since the real interest rates are higher when accounting for deflation.

China is an aging, leveraged country, with excess industrial capacity. Appearances by inflation should be cheered,” according to the CBB Q4 preview. “They are also rare.”

Qazi says that the only inflation is in agriculture commodities, which is not what Beijing wants.

The early signs of deflation are broad-based. Wages, sale prices, and input costs are all trending lower, according to CBB surveys. The November reading on Chinese inflation showed a drop of 0.3 percent. The statistic showed four months of deflation earlier this year before turning positive again.

China’s 10-year government bond yield has been trending lower since the start of the year, partially reflecting the market’s anticipation of deflation worsening and the economy slowing.

Two metals symbolic of global growth—copper and aluminum—are languishing. The CBB reports that the net share of copper firms raising production capacity fell to 30 percent from 60 percent two quarters prior, while aluminum firms raising capacity fell to 18 percent, which is half the Q3 figure.

“Dr. Copper” is not far from its lowest level in a year. Aluminum prices are at their lowest in 18 months.

No Help

“A major misconception presently is that China will announce another massive stimulus plan in the coming weeks,” Qazi said.

He added that further measures to stimulate the economy are unlikely. This is because true fiscal stimulus has never been attempted, and government spending distributed via state banks ends up being akin to monetary accommodation, which is what the Chinese authorities insisted would not happen again under their watch.

“The bottom line is that we see pervasive weakness in the economy as we look to 2019,” Qazi said.

China Beige Book Issues Dire Fourth-Quarter Preview <body> <h1> Array ( [0] => xhina beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [1] => vhina beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [2] => fhina beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [3] => dhina beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [4] => cgina beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [5] => cbina beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [6] => cnina beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [7] => cjina beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [8] => cuina beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [9] => cyina beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [10] => chuna beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [11] => chjna beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [12] => chkna beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [13] => chona beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [14] => ch9na beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [15] => ch8na beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [16] => chiba beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [17] => chima beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [18] => chija beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [19] => chiha beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [20] => chinz beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [21] => chins beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [22] => chinw beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [23] => chinq beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [24] => china veige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [25] => china neige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [26] => china heige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [27] => china geige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [28] => china bwige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [29] => china bsige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [30] => china bdige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [31] => china brige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [32] => china b4ige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [33] => china b3ige book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [34] => china beuge book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [35] => china bejge book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [36] => china bekge book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [37] => china beoge book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [38] => china be9ge book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [39] => china be8ge book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [40] => china beife book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [41] => china beive book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [42] => china beibe book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [43] => china beihe book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [44] => china beiye book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [45] => china beite book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [46] => china beigw book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [47] => china beigs book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [48] => china beigd book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [49] => china beigr book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [50] => china beig4 book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [51] => china beig3 book issues dire fourth-quarter preview [52] => china beige vook issues dire fourth-quarter preview [53] => china beige nook issues dire fourth-quarter preview [54] => china beige hook issues dire fourth-quarter preview [55] => china beige gook issues dire fourth-quarter preview [56] => china beige biok issues dire fourth-quarter preview [57] => china beige bkok issues dire fourth-quarter preview [58] => china beige blok issues dire fourth-quarter preview [59] => china beige bpok issues dire fourth-quarter preview [60] => china beige b0ok issues dire fourth-quarter preview [61] => china beige b9ok issues dire fourth-quarter preview [62] => china beige boik issues dire fourth-quarter preview [63] => china beige bokk issues dire fourth-quarter preview [64] => china beige bolk issues dire fourth-quarter preview [65] => china beige bopk issues dire fourth-quarter preview [66] => china beige bo0k issues dire fourth-quarter preview [67] => china beige bo9k issues dire fourth-quarter preview [68] => china beige booj issues dire fourth-quarter preview [69] => china beige boom issues dire fourth-quarter preview [70] => china beige bool issues dire fourth-quarter preview [71] => china beige booo issues dire fourth-quarter preview [72] => china beige booi issues dire fourth-quarter preview [73] => china beige book ussues dire fourth-quarter preview [74] => china beige book jssues dire fourth-quarter preview [75] => china beige book kssues dire fourth-quarter preview [76] => china beige book ossues dire fourth-quarter preview [77] => china beige book 9ssues dire fourth-quarter preview [78] => china beige book 8ssues dire fourth-quarter preview [79] => china beige book iasues dire fourth-quarter preview [80] => china beige book izsues dire fourth-quarter preview [81] => china beige book ixsues dire fourth-quarter preview [82] => china beige book idsues dire fourth-quarter preview [83] => china beige book iesues dire fourth-quarter preview [84] => china beige book iwsues dire fourth-quarter preview [85] => china beige book isaues dire fourth-quarter preview [86] => china beige book iszues dire fourth-quarter preview [87] => china beige book isxues dire fourth-quarter preview [88] => china beige book isdues dire fourth-quarter preview [89] => china beige book iseues dire fourth-quarter preview [90] => china beige book iswues dire fourth-quarter preview [91] => china beige book issyes dire fourth-quarter preview [92] => china beige book isshes dire fourth-quarter preview [93] => china beige book issjes dire fourth-quarter preview [94] => china beige book issies dire fourth-quarter preview [95] => china beige book iss8es dire fourth-quarter preview [96] => china beige book iss7es dire fourth-quarter preview [97] => china beige book issuws dire fourth-quarter preview [98] => china beige book issuss dire fourth-quarter preview [99] => china beige book issuds dire fourth-quarter preview [100] => china beige book issurs dire fourth-quarter preview [101] => china beige book issu4s dire fourth-quarter preview [102] => china beige book issu3s dire fourth-quarter preview [103] => china beige book issuea dire fourth-quarter preview [104] => china beige book issuez dire fourth-quarter preview [105] => china beige book issuex dire fourth-quarter preview [106] => china beige book issued dire fourth-quarter preview [107] => china beige book issuee dire fourth-quarter preview [108] => china beige book issuew dire fourth-quarter preview [109] => china beige book issues sire fourth-quarter preview [110] => china beige book issues xire fourth-quarter preview [111] => china beige book issues cire fourth-quarter preview [112] => china beige book issues fire fourth-quarter preview [113] => china beige book issues rire fourth-quarter preview [114] => china beige book issues eire fourth-quarter preview [115] => china beige book issues dure fourth-quarter preview [116] => china beige book issues djre fourth-quarter preview [117] => china beige book issues dkre fourth-quarter preview [118] => china beige book issues dore fourth-quarter preview [119] => china beige book issues d9re fourth-quarter preview [120] => china beige book issues d8re fourth-quarter preview [121] => china beige book issues diee fourth-quarter preview [122] => china beige book issues dide fourth-quarter preview [123] => china beige book issues dife fourth-quarter preview [124] => china beige book issues dite fourth-quarter preview [125] => china beige book issues di5e fourth-quarter preview [126] => china beige book issues di4e fourth-quarter preview [127] => china beige book issues dirw fourth-quarter preview [128] => china beige book issues dirs fourth-quarter preview [129] => china beige book issues dird fourth-quarter preview [130] => china beige book issues dirr fourth-quarter preview [131] => china beige book issues dir4 fourth-quarter preview [132] => china beige book issues dir3 fourth-quarter preview [133] => china beige book issues dire dourth-quarter preview [134] => china beige book issues dire courth-quarter preview [135] => china beige book issues dire vourth-quarter preview [136] => china beige book issues dire gourth-quarter preview [137] => china beige book issues dire tourth-quarter preview [138] => china beige book issues dire rourth-quarter preview [139] => china beige book issues dire fiurth-quarter preview [140] => china beige book issues dire fkurth-quarter preview [141] => china beige book issues dire flurth-quarter preview [142] => china beige book issues dire fpurth-quarter preview [143] => china beige book issues dire f0urth-quarter preview [144] => china beige book issues dire f9urth-quarter preview [145] => china beige book issues dire foyrth-quarter preview [146] => china beige book issues dire fohrth-quarter preview [147] => china beige book issues dire fojrth-quarter preview [148] => china beige book issues dire foirth-quarter preview [149] => china beige book issues dire fo8rth-quarter preview [150] => china beige book issues dire fo7rth-quarter preview [151] => china beige book issues dire foueth-quarter preview [152] => china beige book issues dire foudth-quarter preview [153] => china beige book issues dire foufth-quarter preview [154] => china beige book issues dire foutth-quarter preview [155] => china beige book issues dire fou5th-quarter preview [156] => china beige book issues dire fou4th-quarter preview [157] => china beige book issues dire fourrh-quarter preview [158] => china beige book issues dire fourfh-quarter preview [159] => china beige book issues dire fourgh-quarter preview [160] => china beige book issues dire fouryh-quarter preview [161] => china beige book issues dire four6h-quarter preview [162] => china beige book issues dire four5h-quarter preview [163] => china beige book issues dire fourtg-quarter preview [164] => china beige book issues dire fourtb-quarter preview [165] => china beige book issues dire fourtn-quarter preview [166] => china beige book issues dire fourtj-quarter preview [167] => china beige book issues dire fourtu-quarter preview [168] => china beige book issues dire fourty-quarter preview [169] => china beige book issues dire fourth0quarter preview [170] => china beige book issues dire fourthpquarter preview [171] => china beige book issues dire fourth-1uarter preview [172] => china beige book issues dire fourth-2uarter preview [173] => china beige book issues dire fourth-wuarter preview [174] => china beige book issues dire fourth-auarter preview [175] => china beige book issues dire fourth-qyarter preview [176] => china beige book issues dire fourth-qharter preview [177] => china beige book issues dire fourth-qjarter preview [178] => china beige book issues dire fourth-qiarter preview [179] => china beige book issues dire fourth-q8arter preview [180] => china beige book issues dire fourth-q7arter preview [181] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quzrter preview [182] => china beige book issues dire fourth-qusrter preview [183] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quwrter preview [184] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quqrter preview [185] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quaeter preview [186] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quadter preview [187] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quafter preview [188] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quatter preview [189] => china beige book issues dire fourth-qua5ter preview [190] => china beige book issues dire fourth-qua4ter preview [191] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarrer preview [192] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarfer preview [193] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarger preview [194] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quaryer preview [195] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quar6er preview [196] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quar5er preview [197] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quartwr preview [198] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quartsr preview [199] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quartdr preview [200] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quartrr preview [201] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quart4r preview [202] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quart3r preview [203] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quartee preview [204] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarted preview [205] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quartef preview [206] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quartet preview [207] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarte5 preview [208] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarte4 preview [209] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter oreview [210] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter lreview [211] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter -review [212] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter 0review [213] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter peeview [214] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter pdeview [215] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter pfeview [216] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter pteview [217] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter p5eview [218] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter p4eview [219] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prwview [220] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prsview [221] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prdview [222] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prrview [223] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter pr4view [224] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter pr3view [225] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter preciew [226] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prebiew [227] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter pregiew [228] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prefiew [229] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prevuew [230] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prevjew [231] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prevkew [232] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prevoew [233] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prev9ew [234] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter prev8ew [235] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previww [236] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previsw [237] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previdw [238] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previrw [239] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previ4w [240] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previ3w [241] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previeq [242] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previea [243] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previes [244] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previee [245] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previe3 [246] => china beige book issues dire fourth-quarter previe2 ) </h1> </body>