Hertz Is One Recession Away From Bankruptcy

Via BlindersOffResearch.com,

  • Operating income hasn’t covered interest expense since 2015 and the total debt continues to soar.

  • The competition has been pressuring revenue since 2013 and is only getting stronger.

  • 2018 used-vehicle values were as good as it’s going to get.

  • Airline passenger volume falls during recessions and 68% of Hertz’s revenue comes from airport locations.

In a recent interview with Real Vision, I identified Hertz as a good short target. Since the interview, Hertz reported Q4 and full-year earnings (or lack thereof) that were above analyst estimates causing the stock to rally. Most of the improvement that took analysts by surprise was due to the abnormally strong performance in used-vehicle values during 2018 which dropped Hertz’s used-vehicle depreciation per unit by 16% on a year-over-year basis. So is all of the pessimism surrounding Hertz overdone and should the 2018 results be the all-clear signal to buy? Let’s let’s take a closer look.

Used-Vehicle Values

Used-vehicle values play a very important role in the profitability of rental car companies. Put simply, the vehicle expense that rental car companies report is mostly based on the purchase price less the recovery value at disposition. As used-vehicle values increase, the gap between the purchase price and recovery value shrinks which translates into a smaller depreciation amount per vehicle and, under normal conditions, better margins. The opposite happens when used-vehicle values fall. As you can see in the chart below, used-vehicle values and Hertz’s operating income have a strong correlation.

The correlation between operating income and used-vehicle values remained very tight until 2013 (more on this later). As shown by the Black Book Retention Index, used vehicle values have been falling since 2014 and have undoubtedly contributed to the decline in operating income. As I mentioned in my opening statement, used-vehicle values were abnormally high in 2018, and the benefit can be observed by the improvement in operating income.

The big question now is, did 2018 mark a trend change in used-vehicle values or was it a one-time head fake before the downtrend continues? Please click here for a thorough explanation of what drove the strong used-vehicle value performance in 2018 and the likely scenario going forward.

Competition

What I’ve shared with you about used-vehicle values belongs in the expense category, but what about revenue? It’s a well-documented fact that Uber and Lyft have put significant pressure on Hertz’s ability to generate revenue. However, one could argue that rental cars are still more convenient for longer-term use (e.g., multi-day business trips, family vacations, etc). Well, now we a have competitor entering that space as well. Remember, when I said we’d talk later about the tight correlation between used-vehicle values and operating income until 2013? Now is the time. Look at the chart below which compares Hertz’s operating income to Turo’s rental days.

While we can argue that Lyft and Uber might not be direct competitors, it is absolutely undeniable that every Turo transaction represents a transaction lost by traditional rental car companies. Turo is not the only competitor in this space either, GM made it clear that they want a piece of the rental car business when they announced their Maven car sharing service and since then FCA has followed suit.

Crushing Debt

Perhaps one of the best and simplest ways to measure the safety of an investment in a company with debt is by measuring the company’s ability to cover its interest expense with its operating income. The more times over the interest expense is covered by the operating income, the larger the margin of safety should profit fall for unforeseen circumstances.

Hertz’s interest expense has been greater than their operating income for three years in a row, and their total debt continues to soar. Consider what I’ve shared with you so far and ask yourself if this trend is likely to change. What could Hertz possibly do substantially increase revenue and lower expenses in order to pay back their ever-increasing debt over time? If the answer is nothing or not enough, then Hertz is clearly on an unsustainable path.

Revenue Sources

I think I’ve made a strong argument for why even a slight/moderate drop in used-vehicle values combined with the continued pressure from competitors and the ever-increasing interest expense is enough to close the doors at Hertz over time. However, to fully understand the title of this article, it’s important to consider whether Hertz can survive even a mild recession. In 2018, 68% of Hertz’s U.S. revenue came from their airport locations.

Offsetting some of the pressure from recent competition has been a strong and consistent increase in passenger volume of U.S. flights.

As you can see in the chart above, airline passenger volume falls during a recession. Due to the large percentage of revenue that Hertz generates at airports (strong correlation between revenue and passenger volume on U.S. flights before the current onslaught of competition), we can assume that where airline passenger volume goes, Hertz’s revenue will follow. The decline in revenue from 2013 was due to competition, but it was partially offset by strong and steady growth in airline passenger volume. That thought leads us to the next question, can Hertz avoid bankruptcy in a recession where airline passenger volume is likely to drop and used-vehicle values are likely to fall? My guess is no.

Folks, if I’ve failed to explain my view on why Hertz is a good short, I hope that I’ve at least succeeded in showing you why it’s a terrible investment. The stock is very volatile so it’s not impossible to play a game of hot potato profitably from the long side (I don’t recommend it). Hertz can certainly rally as some metrics improve due to market conditions that are completely beyond the company’s control, just don’t be the last one holding the potato when the music stops.

Hertz Is One Recession Away From Bankruptcy <body> <h1> Array ( [0] => gertz is one recession away from bankruptcy [1] => bertz is one recession away from bankruptcy [2] => nertz is one recession away from bankruptcy [3] => jertz is one recession away from bankruptcy [4] => uertz is one recession away from bankruptcy [5] => yertz is one recession away from bankruptcy [6] => hwrtz is one recession away from bankruptcy [7] => hsrtz is one recession away from bankruptcy [8] => hdrtz is one recession away from bankruptcy [9] => hrrtz is one recession away from bankruptcy [10] => h4rtz is one recession away from bankruptcy [11] => h3rtz is one recession away from bankruptcy [12] => heetz is one recession away from bankruptcy [13] => hedtz is one recession away from bankruptcy [14] => heftz is one recession away from bankruptcy [15] => hettz is one recession away from bankruptcy [16] => he5tz is one recession away from bankruptcy [17] => he4tz is one recession away from bankruptcy [18] => herrz is one recession away from bankruptcy [19] => herfz is one recession away from bankruptcy [20] => hergz is one recession away from bankruptcy [21] => heryz is one recession away from bankruptcy [22] => her6z is one recession away from bankruptcy [23] => her5z is one recession away from bankruptcy [24] => hertx is one recession away from bankruptcy [25] => herts is one recession away from bankruptcy [26] => herta is one recession away from bankruptcy [27] => hertz us one recession away from bankruptcy [28] => hertz js one recession away from bankruptcy [29] => hertz ks one recession away from bankruptcy [30] => hertz os one recession away from bankruptcy [31] => hertz 9s one recession away from bankruptcy [32] => hertz 8s one recession away from bankruptcy [33] => hertz ia one recession away from bankruptcy [34] => hertz iz one recession away from bankruptcy [35] => hertz ix one recession away from bankruptcy [36] => hertz id one recession away from bankruptcy [37] => hertz ie one recession away from bankruptcy [38] => hertz iw one recession away from bankruptcy [39] => hertz is ine recession away from bankruptcy [40] => hertz is kne recession away from bankruptcy [41] => hertz is lne recession away from bankruptcy [42] => hertz is pne recession away from bankruptcy [43] => hertz is 0ne recession away from bankruptcy [44] => hertz is 9ne recession away from bankruptcy [45] => hertz is obe recession away from bankruptcy [46] => hertz is ome recession away from bankruptcy [47] => hertz is oje recession away from bankruptcy [48] => hertz is ohe recession away from bankruptcy [49] => hertz is onw recession away from bankruptcy [50] => hertz is ons recession away from bankruptcy [51] => hertz is ond recession away from bankruptcy [52] => hertz is onr recession away from bankruptcy [53] => hertz is on4 recession away from bankruptcy [54] => hertz is on3 recession away from bankruptcy [55] => hertz is one eecession away from bankruptcy [56] => hertz is one decession away from bankruptcy [57] => hertz is one fecession away from bankruptcy [58] => hertz is one tecession away from bankruptcy [59] => hertz is one 5ecession away from bankruptcy [60] => hertz is one 4ecession away from bankruptcy [61] => hertz is one rwcession away from bankruptcy [62] => hertz is one rscession away from bankruptcy [63] => hertz is one rdcession away from bankruptcy [64] => hertz is one rrcession away from bankruptcy [65] => hertz is one r4cession away from bankruptcy [66] => hertz is one r3cession away from bankruptcy [67] => hertz is one rexession away from bankruptcy [68] => hertz is one revession away from bankruptcy [69] => hertz is one refession away from bankruptcy [70] => hertz is one redession away from bankruptcy [71] => hertz is one recwssion away from bankruptcy [72] => hertz is one recsssion away from bankruptcy [73] => hertz is one recdssion away from bankruptcy [74] => hertz is one recrssion away from bankruptcy [75] => hertz is one rec4ssion away from bankruptcy [76] => hertz is one rec3ssion away from bankruptcy [77] => hertz is one receasion away from bankruptcy [78] => hertz is one recezsion away from bankruptcy [79] => hertz is one recexsion away from bankruptcy [80] => hertz is one recedsion away from bankruptcy [81] => hertz is one receesion away from bankruptcy [82] => hertz is one recewsion away from bankruptcy [83] => hertz is one recesaion away from bankruptcy [84] => hertz is one receszion away from bankruptcy [85] => hertz is one recesxion away from bankruptcy [86] => hertz is one recesdion away from bankruptcy [87] => hertz is one receseion away from bankruptcy [88] => hertz is one receswion away from bankruptcy [89] => hertz is one recessuon away from bankruptcy [90] => hertz is one recessjon away from bankruptcy [91] => hertz is one recesskon away from bankruptcy [92] => hertz is one recessoon away from bankruptcy [93] => hertz is one recess9on away from bankruptcy [94] => hertz is one recess8on away from bankruptcy [95] => hertz is one recessiin away from bankruptcy [96] => hertz is one recessikn away from bankruptcy [97] => hertz is one recessiln away from bankruptcy [98] => hertz is one recessipn away from bankruptcy [99] => hertz is one recessi0n away from bankruptcy [100] => hertz is one recessi9n away from bankruptcy [101] => hertz is one recessiob away from bankruptcy [102] => hertz is one recessiom away from bankruptcy [103] => hertz is one recessioj away from bankruptcy [104] => hertz is one recessioh away from bankruptcy [105] => hertz is one recession zway from bankruptcy [106] => hertz is one recession sway from bankruptcy [107] => hertz is one recession wway from bankruptcy [108] => hertz is one recession qway from bankruptcy [109] => hertz is one recession aqay from bankruptcy [110] => hertz is one recession aaay from bankruptcy [111] => hertz is one recession asay from bankruptcy [112] => hertz is one recession aeay from bankruptcy [113] => hertz is one recession a3ay from bankruptcy [114] => hertz is one recession a2ay from bankruptcy [115] => hertz is one recession awzy from bankruptcy [116] => hertz is one recession awsy from bankruptcy [117] => hertz is one recession awwy from bankruptcy [118] => hertz is one recession awqy from bankruptcy [119] => hertz is one recession awat from bankruptcy [120] => hertz is one recession awag from bankruptcy [121] => hertz is one recession awah from bankruptcy [122] => hertz is one recession awau from bankruptcy [123] => hertz is one recession awa7 from bankruptcy [124] => hertz is one recession awa6 from bankruptcy [125] => hertz is one recession away drom bankruptcy [126] => hertz is one recession away crom bankruptcy [127] => hertz is one recession away vrom bankruptcy [128] => hertz is one recession away grom bankruptcy [129] => hertz is one recession away trom bankruptcy [130] => hertz is one recession away rrom bankruptcy [131] => hertz is one recession away feom bankruptcy [132] => hertz is one recession away fdom bankruptcy [133] => hertz is one recession away ffom bankruptcy [134] => hertz is one recession away ftom bankruptcy [135] => hertz is one recession away f5om bankruptcy [136] => hertz is one recession away f4om bankruptcy [137] => hertz is one recession away frim bankruptcy [138] => hertz is one recession away frkm bankruptcy [139] => hertz is one recession away frlm bankruptcy [140] => hertz is one recession away frpm bankruptcy [141] => hertz is one recession away fr0m bankruptcy [142] => hertz is one recession away fr9m bankruptcy [143] => hertz is one recession away fron bankruptcy [144] => hertz is one recession away frok bankruptcy [145] => hertz is one recession away froj bankruptcy [146] => hertz is one recession away from vankruptcy [147] => hertz is one recession away from nankruptcy [148] => hertz is one recession away from hankruptcy [149] => hertz is one recession away from gankruptcy [150] => hertz is one recession away from bznkruptcy [151] => hertz is one recession away from bsnkruptcy [152] => hertz is one recession away from bwnkruptcy [153] => hertz is one recession away from bqnkruptcy [154] => hertz is one recession away from babkruptcy [155] => hertz is one recession away from bamkruptcy [156] => hertz is one recession away from bajkruptcy [157] => hertz is one recession away from bahkruptcy [158] => hertz is one recession away from banjruptcy [159] => hertz is one recession away from banmruptcy [160] => hertz is one recession away from banlruptcy [161] => hertz is one recession away from banoruptcy [162] => hertz is one recession away from baniruptcy [163] => hertz is one recession away from bankeuptcy [164] => hertz is one recession away from bankduptcy [165] => hertz is one recession away from bankfuptcy [166] => hertz is one recession away from banktuptcy [167] => hertz is one recession away from bank5uptcy [168] => hertz is one recession away from bank4uptcy [169] => hertz is one recession away from bankryptcy [170] => hertz is one recession away from bankrhptcy [171] => hertz is one recession away from bankrjptcy [172] => hertz is one recession away from bankriptcy [173] => hertz is one recession away from bankr8ptcy [174] => hertz is one recession away from bankr7ptcy [175] => hertz is one recession away from bankruotcy [176] => hertz is one recession away from bankrultcy [177] => hertz is one recession away from bankru-tcy [178] => hertz is one recession away from bankru0tcy [179] => hertz is one recession away from bankruprcy [180] => hertz is one recession away from bankrupfcy [181] => hertz is one recession away from bankrupgcy [182] => hertz is one recession away from bankrupycy [183] => hertz is one recession away from bankrup6cy [184] => hertz is one recession away from bankrup5cy [185] => hertz is one recession away from bankruptxy [186] => hertz is one recession away from bankruptvy [187] => hertz is one recession away from bankruptfy [188] => hertz is one recession away from bankruptdy [189] => hertz is one recession away from bankruptct [190] => hertz is one recession away from bankruptcg [191] => hertz is one recession away from bankruptch [192] => hertz is one recession away from bankruptcu [193] => hertz is one recession away from bankruptc7 [194] => hertz is one recession away from bankruptc6 ) </h1> </body>