NSA Abandons Part Of Mass Surveillance Program Exposed By Snowden

The National Security Agency (NSA) has reportedly abandoned part of their infamous surveillance apparatus exposed by former contractor Edward Snowden, and used for the mass collection of Americans’ communications records; including phone logs, metadata and text messages.

The New York Times noted that House minority leader national security adviser Luke Murry told The Lawfare Podcast that the NSA “hasn’t actually been using it for the past six months,” and that he’s “not certain that the [Trump] administration will want to start that back up” (despite collecting 530 million US phone records in 2017)

Keep in mind, the NYT report isn’t claiming the NSA has abandoned other programs such as XKeyscore – which the agency uses to search and analyze global internet data. When asked by German broadcaster Norddeutscher Rundfunk “What could you do if you would use XKeyscore?” Edward Snowden replied:

You could read anyone’s email in the world, anybody you’ve got an email address for. Any website: You can watch traffic to and from it. Any computer that an individual sits at: You can watch it. Any laptop that you’re tracking: you can follow it as it moves from place to place throughout the world. It’s a one-stop-shop for access to the NSA’s information.

… You can tag individuals … Let’s say you work at a major German corporation and I want access to that network, I can track your username on a website on a form somewhere, I can track your real name, I can track associations with your friends and I can build what’s called a fingerprint, which is network activity unique to you, which means anywhere you go in the world, anywhere you try to sort of hide your online presence, your identity. –Edward Snowden

Of note, former Director of National Intelligence, James Clapper, was caught lying to Congress about the NSA’s bulk data collection. In response to a 2013 question by Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR) “Does the NSA collect any type of data at all on millions, or hundreds of millions, of Americans?,” Clapper replied: “No sir, not wittingly.”

Instead of a DOJ subpoena for lying to Congress, Clapper now collects a paycheck as a CNN contributor.

Initiated under President George W. Bush in 2001 in the wake of the Sept. 11 attacks and exposed by intelligence contractor Edward Snowden, the bulk metadata collection program was scaled back under the 2015 Freedom Act – set to expire this year, which kept records in the hands of carriers such as AT&T and Verizon that could quickly be accessed via a court order.

Yet the scale of collection remained huge: The program gathered 151 million records in 2016, despite obtaining court orders to use the system on only 42 terrorism suspects in 2016, along with a few left over from late 2015. In 2017, it obtained orders for 40 targets and collected 534 million records.

Problems with the system emerged last year, when the National Security Agency said it had decided to delete its entire database of records gathered since the Freedom Act system became operational. Glenn S. Gerstell, the agency’s general counsel, said in an interview at the time that because of complex technical glitches, one or more telecom providers — he declined to say which — had responded to court orders for records by sending logs to the agency that included both accurate and inaccurate data. –New York Times

Last year the NSA acknowledged that due to “technical problems,” it collected records on people in the US that it did not have the authority to surveil. As a result, the records were reportedly purged.

The agency issued a statement in June notifying the public that in May it began to delete all so-called “call detail records” (CDRs) collected since 2015.

CDRs are handed over by telecommunications providers, and contain metadata – including phone numbers as well as the time and duration of phone calls. The actual content of the calls themselves is not monitored by this system. Skype (and therefore Microsoft), however, provides a bit more to the US Government as revealed by Edward Snowden – handing the NSA “buddy lists, credit card data, call records and user account information,” and possibly the plaintext inside of messages, according to Arstechnica.

To that end, the “shocking” 2017 figure of 534 million CDRs collected pales in comparison to the estimated billions of records collected each day under the older NSA bulk collection system – an earlier iteration of which was exposed by NSA whistleblower William Binney.

Since it’s unlikely that the US government has kicked its addiction to surveillance, one can only imagine that the NSA has moved on to bigger and better technologies to keep us all ‘safe.’

NSA Abandons Part Of Mass Surveillance Program Exposed By Snowden <body> <h1> Array ( [0] => bsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [1] => msa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [2] => jsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [3] => hsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [4] => naa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [5] => nza abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [6] => nxa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [7] => nda abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [8] => nea abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [9] => nwa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [10] => nsz abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [11] => nss abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [12] => nsw abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [13] => nsq abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [14] => nsa zbandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [15] => nsa sbandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [16] => nsa wbandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [17] => nsa qbandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [18] => nsa avandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [19] => nsa anandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [20] => nsa ahandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [21] => nsa agandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [22] => nsa abzndons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [23] => nsa absndons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [24] => nsa abwndons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [25] => nsa abqndons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [26] => nsa ababdons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [27] => nsa abamdons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [28] => nsa abajdons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [29] => nsa abahdons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [30] => nsa abansons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [31] => nsa abanxons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [32] => nsa abancons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [33] => nsa abanfons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [34] => nsa abanrons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [35] => nsa abaneons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [36] => nsa abandins part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [37] => nsa abandkns part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [38] => nsa abandlns part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [39] => nsa abandpns part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [40] => nsa aband0ns part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [41] => nsa aband9ns part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [42] => nsa abandobs part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [43] => nsa abandoms part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [44] => nsa abandojs part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [45] => nsa abandohs part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [46] => nsa abandona part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [47] => nsa abandonz part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [48] => nsa abandonx part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [49] => nsa abandond part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [50] => nsa abandone part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [51] => nsa abandonw part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [52] => nsa abandons oart of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [53] => nsa abandons lart of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [54] => nsa abandons -art of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [55] => nsa abandons 0art of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [56] => nsa abandons pzrt of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [57] => nsa abandons psrt of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [58] => nsa abandons pwrt of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [59] => nsa abandons pqrt of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [60] => nsa abandons paet of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [61] => nsa abandons padt of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [62] => nsa abandons paft of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [63] => nsa abandons patt of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [64] => nsa abandons pa5t of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [65] => nsa abandons pa4t of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [66] => nsa abandons parr of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [67] => nsa abandons parf of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [68] => nsa abandons parg of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [69] => nsa abandons pary of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [70] => nsa abandons par6 of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [71] => nsa abandons par5 of mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [72] => nsa abandons part if mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [73] => nsa abandons part kf mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [74] => nsa abandons part lf mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [75] => nsa abandons part pf mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [76] => nsa abandons part 0f mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [77] => nsa abandons part 9f mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [78] => nsa abandons part od mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [79] => nsa abandons part oc mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [80] => nsa abandons part ov mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [81] => nsa abandons part og mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [82] => nsa abandons part ot mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [83] => nsa abandons part or mass surveillance program exposed by snowden [84] => nsa abandons part of nass surveillance program exposed by snowden [85] => nsa abandons part of kass surveillance program exposed by snowden [86] => nsa abandons part of jass surveillance program exposed by snowden [87] => nsa abandons part of mzss surveillance program exposed by snowden [88] => nsa abandons part of msss surveillance program exposed by snowden [89] => nsa abandons part of mwss surveillance program exposed by snowden [90] => nsa abandons part of mqss surveillance program exposed by snowden [91] => nsa abandons part of maas surveillance program exposed by snowden [92] => nsa abandons part of mazs surveillance program exposed by snowden [93] => nsa abandons part of maxs surveillance program exposed by snowden [94] => nsa abandons part of mads surveillance program exposed by snowden [95] => nsa abandons part of maes surveillance program exposed by snowden [96] => nsa abandons part of maws surveillance program exposed by snowden [97] => nsa abandons part of masa surveillance program exposed by snowden [98] => nsa abandons part of masz surveillance program exposed by snowden [99] => nsa abandons part of masx surveillance program exposed by snowden [100] => nsa abandons part of masd surveillance program exposed by snowden [101] => nsa abandons part of mase surveillance program exposed by snowden [102] => nsa abandons part of masw surveillance program exposed by snowden [103] => nsa abandons part of mass aurveillance program exposed by snowden [104] => nsa abandons part of mass zurveillance program exposed by snowden [105] => nsa abandons part of mass xurveillance program exposed by snowden [106] => nsa abandons part of mass durveillance program exposed by snowden [107] => nsa abandons part of mass eurveillance program exposed by snowden [108] => nsa abandons part of mass wurveillance program exposed by snowden [109] => nsa abandons part of mass syrveillance program exposed by snowden [110] => nsa abandons part of mass shrveillance program exposed by snowden [111] => nsa abandons part of mass sjrveillance program exposed by snowden [112] => nsa abandons part of mass sirveillance program exposed by snowden [113] => nsa abandons part of mass s8rveillance program exposed by snowden [114] => nsa abandons part of mass s7rveillance program exposed by snowden [115] => nsa abandons part of mass sueveillance program exposed by snowden [116] => nsa abandons part of mass sudveillance program exposed by snowden [117] => nsa abandons part of mass sufveillance program exposed by snowden [118] => nsa abandons part of mass sutveillance program exposed by snowden [119] => nsa abandons part of mass su5veillance program exposed by snowden [120] => nsa abandons part of mass su4veillance program exposed by snowden [121] => nsa abandons part of mass surceillance program exposed by snowden [122] => nsa abandons part of mass surbeillance program exposed by snowden [123] => nsa abandons part of mass surgeillance program exposed by snowden [124] => nsa abandons part of mass surfeillance program exposed by snowden [125] => nsa abandons part of mass survwillance program exposed by snowden [126] => nsa abandons part of mass survsillance program exposed by snowden [127] => nsa abandons part of mass survdillance program exposed by snowden [128] => nsa abandons part of mass survrillance program exposed by snowden [129] => nsa abandons part of mass surv4illance program exposed by snowden [130] => nsa abandons part of mass surv3illance program exposed by snowden [131] => nsa abandons part of mass surveullance program exposed by snowden [132] => nsa abandons part of mass survejllance program exposed by snowden [133] => nsa abandons part of mass survekllance program exposed by snowden [134] => nsa abandons part of mass surveollance program exposed by snowden [135] => nsa abandons part of mass surve9llance program exposed by snowden [136] => nsa abandons part of mass surve8llance program exposed by snowden [137] => nsa abandons part of mass surveiklance program exposed by snowden [138] => nsa abandons part of mass surveiplance program exposed by snowden [139] => nsa abandons part of mass surveiolance program exposed by snowden [140] => nsa abandons part of mass surveilkance program exposed by snowden [141] => nsa abandons part of mass surveilpance program exposed by snowden [142] => nsa abandons part of mass surveiloance program exposed by snowden [143] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillznce program exposed by snowden [144] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillsnce program exposed by snowden [145] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillwnce program exposed by snowden [146] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillqnce program exposed by snowden [147] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillabce program exposed by snowden [148] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillamce program exposed by snowden [149] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillajce program exposed by snowden [150] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillahce program exposed by snowden [151] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillanxe program exposed by snowden [152] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillanve program exposed by snowden [153] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillanfe program exposed by snowden [154] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillande program exposed by snowden [155] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillancw program exposed by snowden [156] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillancs program exposed by snowden [157] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillancd program exposed by snowden [158] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillancr program exposed by snowden [159] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillanc4 program exposed by snowden [160] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillanc3 program exposed by snowden [161] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance orogram exposed by snowden [162] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance lrogram exposed by snowden [163] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance -rogram exposed by snowden [164] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance 0rogram exposed by snowden [165] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance peogram exposed by snowden [166] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance pdogram exposed by snowden [167] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance pfogram exposed by snowden [168] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance ptogram exposed by snowden [169] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance p5ogram exposed by snowden [170] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance p4ogram exposed by snowden [171] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance prigram exposed by snowden [172] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance prkgram exposed by snowden [173] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance prlgram exposed by snowden [174] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance prpgram exposed by snowden [175] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance pr0gram exposed by snowden [176] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance pr9gram exposed by snowden [177] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance profram exposed by snowden [178] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance provram exposed by snowden [179] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance probram exposed by snowden [180] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance prohram exposed by snowden [181] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance proyram exposed by snowden [182] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance protram exposed by snowden [183] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance progeam exposed by snowden [184] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance progdam exposed by snowden [185] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance progfam exposed by snowden [186] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance progtam exposed by snowden [187] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance prog5am exposed by snowden [188] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance prog4am exposed by snowden [189] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance progrzm exposed by snowden [190] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance progrsm exposed by snowden [191] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance progrwm exposed by snowden [192] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance progrqm exposed by snowden [193] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance progran exposed by snowden [194] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance prograk exposed by snowden [195] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance prograj exposed by snowden [196] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program wxposed by snowden [197] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program sxposed by snowden [198] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program dxposed by snowden [199] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program rxposed by snowden [200] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program 4xposed by snowden [201] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program 3xposed by snowden [202] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program ezposed by snowden [203] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program ecposed by snowden [204] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program edposed by snowden [205] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program esposed by snowden [206] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exoosed by snowden [207] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exlosed by snowden [208] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program ex-osed by snowden [209] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program ex0osed by snowden [210] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program expised by snowden [211] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program expksed by snowden [212] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program explsed by snowden [213] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exppsed by snowden [214] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exp0sed by snowden [215] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exp9sed by snowden [216] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program expoaed by snowden [217] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program expozed by snowden [218] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program expoxed by snowden [219] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program expoded by snowden [220] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program expoeed by snowden [221] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program expowed by snowden [222] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposwd by snowden [223] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program expossd by snowden [224] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposdd by snowden [225] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposrd by snowden [226] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program expos4d by snowden [227] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program expos3d by snowden [228] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposes by snowden [229] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposex by snowden [230] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposec by snowden [231] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposef by snowden [232] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposer by snowden [233] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposee by snowden [234] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed vy snowden [235] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed ny snowden [236] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed hy snowden [237] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed gy snowden [238] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed bt snowden [239] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed bg snowden [240] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed bh snowden [241] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed bu snowden [242] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed b7 snowden [243] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed b6 snowden [244] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by anowden [245] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by znowden [246] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by xnowden [247] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by dnowden [248] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by enowden [249] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by wnowden [250] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by sbowden [251] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by smowden [252] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by sjowden [253] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by showden [254] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by sniwden [255] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snkwden [256] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snlwden [257] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snpwden [258] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by sn0wden [259] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by sn9wden [260] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snoqden [261] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snoaden [262] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snosden [263] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snoeden [264] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by sno3den [265] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by sno2den [266] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowsen [267] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowxen [268] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowcen [269] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowfen [270] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowren [271] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snoween [272] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowdwn [273] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowdsn [274] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowddn [275] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowdrn [276] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowd4n [277] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowd3n [278] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowdeb [279] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowdem [280] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowdej [281] => nsa abandons part of mass surveillance program exposed by snowdeh ) </h1> </body>