The Anatomy Of A Government Shutdown

Authored by Chris Calton via The Mises Institute,

Thomas Sowell used to ask his students to imagine a government bureaucracy that had two functions. One function was to provide medicine to sick children, and the other function was to construct statues of Benedict Arnold. He would then ask his students that if the bureaucracy suffered budget cuts, which function would the bureau stop funding?

The intuitive answer to those of us who are not bureaucrats is to cut the funding to Benedict Arnold statues, of course. One might even ask why we are funding statues in honor of a traitor to begin with? But, Sowell would tell his students, the bureaucracy would actually be more inclined to cut funding to the medicine to sick children.

Why?

Bureaucrats and politicians, like anybody else, are self-interested individuals, and their interests are to enjoy a bureaucracy with as large a tax-payer-funded budget as possible. When they are faced with budget cuts, it makes no sense to cut funding from programs that the vast majority of taxpayers wouldn’t care to fund in the first place. There would be no outcry. But by cutting funds in an area that creates real pain for certain people within the population — say, sick children or members of the military — the public will predictably erupt with outrage, demanding that the original budget be reinstated (or even increased!) so people don’t suffer.

With President Trump’s demands for tax-payer funds allocated to his border wall, his reaction was to threaten a government shutdown. This tactic seems to be an increasingly popular tactic for politicians who want support for ever-increasing budgets and higher taxes. The last so-called “shut down” only took place five years ago under Barack Obama, and it seems many people have already forgotten the political theater that accompanied it. “Shutting down” the government apparently meant paying government employees to set up traffic cones around monuments and abstaining from making Twitter updates, among other things.

However, while government continued to spend on things such as subsidies to encourage people to eat Idaho-produced caviar and, apparently until only recently, Y2K prevention research, the shutdowns did included the halting of military pay. Of course, as is the nature with military service, the government’s refusal to pay does not release any service member from their legally enforced obligation to complete their term. But just as Dr. Sowell predicted, the mere threat of government employees — military especially — going without paychecks inevitably brings public outrage and calls to pass whatever budget the president demands. No need to even discuss cutting out any of the billions of dollars identified as waste even by non-libertarian organizations .

The reality with government shutdowns is that nearly nothing actually gets shut down. Heaven forbid employees from the Internal Revenue Service go without pay, let alone the politicians themselves. The specter of a government shutdown, accompanied with media interviews from government employees worrying about paying for Christmas presents, is all that’s needed to bully the public into supporting even the most reviled programs.

In the most recent example, Trump has threatened a government shutdown to compel congress to approve funding for a border wall. A recent GoFundMe campaign has demonstrated both that there are people willing to donate their own money – without compulsory taxes – to the project, but also that nowhere nearly enough taxpayers are willing to fund a border wall to the dollar amount that Congress has approved. But with the threat of a so-called “government shutdown,” ever ardent opponents of Trump’s wall have demanded Congress do whatever it takes to prevent the horrors that demagogues predict will ensue.

For libertarians, it’s easy to celebrate the promise of a government shutdown. Unfortunately, even if the threat is carried out, the sad reality is that a government shutdown is not, and never has been, anything more than an engineered tactic to generate a public outcry to allow the government to tax and spend as much as and however it wants.

And the tactic always seems to work.

The Anatomy Of A Government Shutdown <body> <h1> Array ( [0] => rhe anatomy of a government shutdown [1] => fhe anatomy of a government shutdown [2] => ghe anatomy of a government shutdown [3] => yhe anatomy of a government shutdown [4] => 6he anatomy of a government shutdown [5] => 5he anatomy of a government shutdown [6] => tge anatomy of a government shutdown [7] => tbe anatomy of a government shutdown [8] => tne anatomy of a government shutdown [9] => tje anatomy of a government shutdown [10] => tue anatomy of a government shutdown [11] => tye anatomy of a government shutdown [12] => thw anatomy of a government shutdown [13] => ths anatomy of a government shutdown [14] => thd anatomy of a government shutdown [15] => thr anatomy of a government shutdown [16] => th4 anatomy of a government shutdown [17] => th3 anatomy of a government shutdown [18] => the znatomy of a government shutdown [19] => the snatomy of a government shutdown [20] => the wnatomy of a government shutdown [21] => the qnatomy of a government shutdown [22] => the abatomy of a government shutdown [23] => the amatomy of a government shutdown [24] => the ajatomy of a government shutdown [25] => the ahatomy of a government shutdown [26] => the anztomy of a government shutdown [27] => the anstomy of a government shutdown [28] => the anwtomy of a government shutdown [29] => the anqtomy of a government shutdown [30] => the anaromy of a government shutdown [31] => the anafomy of a government shutdown [32] => the anagomy of a government shutdown [33] => the anayomy of a government shutdown [34] => the ana6omy of a government shutdown [35] => the ana5omy of a government shutdown [36] => the anatimy of a government shutdown [37] => the anatkmy of a government shutdown [38] => the anatlmy of a government shutdown [39] => the anatpmy of a government shutdown [40] => the anat0my of a government shutdown [41] => the anat9my of a government shutdown [42] => the anatony of a government shutdown [43] => the anatoky of a government shutdown [44] => the anatojy of a government shutdown [45] => the anatomt of a government shutdown [46] => the anatomg of a government shutdown [47] => the anatomh of a government shutdown [48] => the anatomu of a government shutdown [49] => the anatom7 of a government shutdown [50] => the anatom6 of a government shutdown [51] => the anatomy if a government shutdown [52] => the anatomy kf a government shutdown [53] => the anatomy lf a government shutdown [54] => the anatomy pf a government shutdown [55] => the anatomy 0f a government shutdown [56] => the anatomy 9f a government shutdown [57] => the anatomy od a government shutdown [58] => the anatomy oc a government shutdown [59] => the anatomy ov a government shutdown [60] => the anatomy og a government shutdown [61] => the anatomy ot a government shutdown [62] => the anatomy or a government shutdown [63] => the anatomy of z government shutdown [64] => the anatomy of s government shutdown [65] => the anatomy of w government shutdown [66] => the anatomy of q government shutdown [67] => the anatomy of a fovernment shutdown [68] => the anatomy of a vovernment shutdown [69] => the anatomy of a bovernment shutdown [70] => the anatomy of a hovernment shutdown [71] => the anatomy of a yovernment shutdown [72] => the anatomy of a tovernment shutdown [73] => the anatomy of a givernment shutdown [74] => the anatomy of a gkvernment shutdown [75] => the anatomy of a glvernment shutdown [76] => the anatomy of a gpvernment shutdown [77] => the anatomy of a g0vernment shutdown [78] => the anatomy of a g9vernment shutdown [79] => the anatomy of a gocernment shutdown [80] => the anatomy of a gobernment shutdown [81] => the anatomy of a gogernment shutdown [82] => the anatomy of a gofernment shutdown [83] => the anatomy of a govwrnment shutdown [84] => the anatomy of a govsrnment shutdown [85] => the anatomy of a govdrnment shutdown [86] => the anatomy of a govrrnment shutdown [87] => the anatomy of a gov4rnment shutdown [88] => the anatomy of a gov3rnment shutdown [89] => the anatomy of a goveenment shutdown [90] => the anatomy of a govednment shutdown [91] => the anatomy of a govefnment shutdown [92] => the anatomy of a govetnment shutdown [93] => the anatomy of a gove5nment shutdown [94] => the anatomy of a gove4nment shutdown [95] => the anatomy of a goverbment shutdown [96] => the anatomy of a govermment shutdown [97] => the anatomy of a goverjment shutdown [98] => the anatomy of a goverhment shutdown [99] => the anatomy of a governnent shutdown [100] => the anatomy of a governkent shutdown [101] => the anatomy of a governjent shutdown [102] => the anatomy of a governmwnt shutdown [103] => the anatomy of a governmsnt shutdown [104] => the anatomy of a governmdnt shutdown [105] => the anatomy of a governmrnt shutdown [106] => the anatomy of a governm4nt shutdown [107] => the anatomy of a governm3nt shutdown [108] => the anatomy of a governmebt shutdown [109] => the anatomy of a governmemt shutdown [110] => the anatomy of a governmejt shutdown [111] => the anatomy of a governmeht shutdown [112] => the anatomy of a governmenr shutdown [113] => the anatomy of a governmenf shutdown [114] => the anatomy of a governmeng shutdown [115] => the anatomy of a governmeny shutdown [116] => the anatomy of a governmen6 shutdown [117] => the anatomy of a governmen5 shutdown [118] => the anatomy of a government ahutdown [119] => the anatomy of a government zhutdown [120] => the anatomy of a government xhutdown [121] => the anatomy of a government dhutdown [122] => the anatomy of a government ehutdown [123] => the anatomy of a government whutdown [124] => the anatomy of a government sgutdown [125] => the anatomy of a government sbutdown [126] => the anatomy of a government snutdown [127] => the anatomy of a government sjutdown [128] => the anatomy of a government suutdown [129] => the anatomy of a government syutdown [130] => the anatomy of a government shytdown [131] => the anatomy of a government shhtdown [132] => the anatomy of a government shjtdown [133] => the anatomy of a government shitdown [134] => the anatomy of a government sh8tdown [135] => the anatomy of a government sh7tdown [136] => the anatomy of a government shurdown [137] => the anatomy of a government shufdown [138] => the anatomy of a government shugdown [139] => the anatomy of a government shuydown [140] => the anatomy of a government shu6down [141] => the anatomy of a government shu5down [142] => the anatomy of a government shutsown [143] => the anatomy of a government shutxown [144] => the anatomy of a government shutcown [145] => the anatomy of a government shutfown [146] => the anatomy of a government shutrown [147] => the anatomy of a government shuteown [148] => the anatomy of a government shutdiwn [149] => the anatomy of a government shutdkwn [150] => the anatomy of a government shutdlwn [151] => the anatomy of a government shutdpwn [152] => the anatomy of a government shutd0wn [153] => the anatomy of a government shutd9wn [154] => the anatomy of a government shutdoqn [155] => the anatomy of a government shutdoan [156] => the anatomy of a government shutdosn [157] => the anatomy of a government shutdoen [158] => the anatomy of a government shutdo3n [159] => the anatomy of a government shutdo2n [160] => the anatomy of a government shutdowb [161] => the anatomy of a government shutdowm [162] => the anatomy of a government shutdowj [163] => the anatomy of a government shutdowh ) </h1> </body>