This Key Indicator Spells Trouble For Oil Investors

Authored by Nick Cunningham via Oilprice.com,

The price ratio between crude oil and natural gas has changed dramatically in the past few weeks, as crude prices have crashed at a time when natural gas prices hit multi-year highs. The ratio between the two prices could have consequences for a variety of natural gas and petrochemical projects, potentially leading to delays or cancellations.

Oil typically trades at a premium relative to natural gas, but at the end of November, the price ratio of Brent crude to Henry Hub gas fell to its lowest level since 2009.

“The relative price of oil and gas affects the economics of various infrastructure investments across the energy industry, and the recent falloff might act as a fly in the ointment to development plans in the short term and could lead to delays,” Barclays said in a report.

The reasons for the plunge in oil prices have been discussed at length in this column and elsewhere – demand looks shaky, U.S. supply is soaring and oil traders are skeptical about the ability and willingness of OPEC+ to balance the market.

Meanwhile, natural gas has gone in the opposite direction over the past two months or so. Low inventories, high demand and seasonal factors have dramatically tightened the market for natural gas in the United States. Prices hit $4.70/MMBtu in November, up 60 percent since September.

In other words, Brent has lost more than half of its price premium to Henry Hub in the last few months.

(Click to enlarge)

There could be fallout for proposed LNG projects because of this development. The fall of global crude prices has also dragged down global LNG prices (LNG prices are still influenced by crude benchmarks). So, we have falling LNG prices around the world, but rising natural gas prices in the United States. The business case for exporting LNG from the U.S. has always been about taking advantage of a cheap feedstock, and selling it abroad at a higher price.

With costs for the feedstock rising, and the landing price falling, the economics of building new LNG projects in the U.S. have taking a hit. January NYMEX gas prices are trading $4/MMBtu below Asian contract LNG prices, a differential that was as high as $9/MMBtu this past summer. The window for profits on shipping LNG from the U.S. to Asia has not entirely closed, but the business case looks a lot less compelling.

That isn’t a big deal for LNG export terminals already online, but it could cause developers of new projects to think twice. “Recent history suggests that the contraction in the oil-gas ratio could lead to project delays, particularly for those projects that are further behind in the process,” Barclays notes.

However, there are several reasons why this could merely be a temporary problem.

First, the oil-to-gas pricing ratio could rebound.

“[W]e believe this oil-gas ratio is due for a retracement, as we see the price movements in oil and gas as overdone,” Barclays said.

The investment bank sees the Brent-Henry Hub ratio doubling from around 15 times to 27-28 times by the second quarter of 2019. The OPEC+ cuts should help rescue oil prices to some degree, while record-setting natural gas production should replenish inventories after the winter season and push prices back down. Barclays sees Brent rising to $75 per barrel in the second quarter of 2019 while gas could fall back to as low as $2.67/MMBtu, allowing oil to regain its strong premium over gas.

A second reason why the lower oil-to-gas pricing ratio may not deter LNG investment is that most LNG developers look at futures prices several years out, and the futures curve for oil-to-gas several years from now still looks convincing, even as the near-term differentials have deteriorated. As such, developers may been unbowed as they plan new projects.

Nevertheless, the sudden downturn in project economics could still force some delayed decisions.

“Although we believe the Brent-Henry Hub will revert in the coming months, the current downturn represents a potential headwind to those US LNG export projects looking to reach final investment decision (FID) over the next year and become one of the ‘second wave’ of LNG terminals,” Barclays concluded.

To top it off, the U.S.-China trade war may magnify uncertainties. China is set to be the largest source of LNG demand growth going forward, so “long-term supply contracts from Chinese offtakers will be critical to underwriting financing for second wave US LNG projects,” Barclays says. China has already slapped a 10 percent tariff on American LNG, a levy that could rise to 25 percent if the two sides can’t come to an agreement by March.

There are several dozen LNG projects planned in North America, totaling $275 billion in potential investment, according to Barclays’ calculations. Obviously, not all – or even most – of those projects will move forward. But the suddenly weak oil-to-gas pricing ratio, combined with the U.S.-China trade war, acts as “an additional hindrance to development,” the investment bank concludes.

 

 

This Key Indicator Spells Trouble For Oil Investors <body> <h1> Array ( [0] => rhis key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [1] => fhis key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [2] => ghis key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [3] => yhis key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [4] => 6his key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [5] => 5his key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [6] => tgis key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [7] => tbis key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [8] => tnis key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [9] => tjis key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [10] => tuis key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [11] => tyis key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [12] => thus key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [13] => thjs key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [14] => thks key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [15] => thos key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [16] => th9s key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [17] => th8s key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [18] => thia key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [19] => thiz key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [20] => thix key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [21] => thid key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [22] => thie key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [23] => thiw key indicator spells trouble for oil investors [24] => this jey indicator spells trouble for oil investors [25] => this mey indicator spells trouble for oil investors [26] => this ley indicator spells trouble for oil investors [27] => this oey indicator spells trouble for oil investors [28] => this iey indicator spells trouble for oil investors [29] => this kwy indicator spells trouble for oil investors [30] => this ksy indicator spells trouble for oil investors [31] => this kdy indicator spells trouble for oil investors [32] => this kry indicator spells trouble for oil investors [33] => this k4y indicator spells trouble for oil investors [34] => this k3y indicator spells trouble for oil investors [35] => this ket indicator spells trouble for oil investors [36] => this keg indicator spells trouble for oil investors [37] => this keh indicator spells trouble for oil investors [38] => this keu indicator spells trouble for oil investors [39] => this ke7 indicator spells trouble for oil investors [40] => this ke6 indicator spells trouble for oil investors [41] => this key undicator spells trouble for oil investors [42] => this key jndicator spells trouble for oil investors [43] => this key kndicator spells trouble for oil investors [44] => this key ondicator spells trouble for oil investors [45] => this key 9ndicator spells trouble for oil investors [46] => this key 8ndicator spells trouble for oil investors [47] => this key ibdicator spells trouble for oil investors [48] => this key imdicator spells trouble for oil investors [49] => this key ijdicator spells trouble for oil investors [50] => this key ihdicator spells trouble for oil investors [51] => this key insicator spells trouble for oil investors [52] => this key inxicator spells trouble for oil investors [53] => this key incicator spells trouble for oil investors [54] => this key inficator spells trouble for oil investors [55] => this key inricator spells trouble for oil investors [56] => this key ineicator spells trouble for oil investors [57] => this key inducator spells trouble for oil investors [58] => this key indjcator spells trouble for oil investors [59] => this key indkcator spells trouble for oil investors [60] => this key indocator spells trouble for oil investors [61] => this key ind9cator spells trouble for oil investors [62] => this key ind8cator spells trouble for oil investors [63] => this key indixator spells trouble for oil investors [64] => this key indivator spells trouble for oil investors [65] => this key indifator spells trouble for oil investors [66] => this key indidator spells trouble for oil investors [67] => this key indicztor spells trouble for oil investors [68] => this key indicstor spells trouble for oil investors [69] => this key indicwtor spells trouble for oil investors [70] => this key indicqtor spells trouble for oil investors [71] => this key indicaror spells trouble for oil investors [72] => this key indicafor spells trouble for oil investors [73] => this key indicagor spells trouble for oil investors [74] => this key indicayor spells trouble for oil investors [75] => this key indica6or spells trouble for oil investors [76] => this key indica5or spells trouble for oil investors [77] => this key indicatir spells trouble for oil investors [78] => this key indicatkr spells trouble for oil investors [79] => this key indicatlr spells trouble for oil investors [80] => this key indicatpr spells trouble for oil investors [81] => this key indicat0r spells trouble for oil investors [82] => this key indicat9r spells trouble for oil investors [83] => this key indicatoe spells trouble for oil investors [84] => this key indicatod spells trouble for oil investors [85] => this key indicatof spells trouble for oil investors [86] => this key indicatot spells trouble for oil investors [87] => this key indicato5 spells trouble for oil investors [88] => this key indicato4 spells trouble for oil investors [89] => this key indicator apells trouble for oil investors [90] => this key indicator zpells trouble for oil investors [91] => this key indicator xpells trouble for oil investors [92] => this key indicator dpells trouble for oil investors [93] => this key indicator epells trouble for oil investors [94] => this key indicator wpells trouble for oil investors [95] => this key indicator soells trouble for oil investors [96] => this key indicator slells trouble for oil investors [97] => this key indicator s-ells trouble for oil investors [98] => this key indicator s0ells trouble for oil investors [99] => this key indicator spwlls trouble for oil investors [100] => this key indicator spslls trouble for oil investors [101] => this key indicator spdlls trouble for oil investors [102] => this key indicator sprlls trouble for oil investors [103] => this key indicator sp4lls trouble for oil investors [104] => this key indicator sp3lls trouble for oil investors [105] => this key indicator spekls trouble for oil investors [106] => this key indicator spepls trouble for oil investors [107] => this key indicator speols trouble for oil investors [108] => this key indicator spelks trouble for oil investors [109] => this key indicator spelps trouble for oil investors [110] => this key indicator spelos trouble for oil investors [111] => this key indicator spella trouble for oil investors [112] => this key indicator spellz trouble for oil investors [113] => this key indicator spellx trouble for oil investors [114] => this key indicator spelld trouble for oil investors [115] => this key indicator spelle trouble for oil investors [116] => this key indicator spellw trouble for oil investors [117] => this key indicator spells rrouble for oil investors [118] => this key indicator spells frouble for oil investors [119] => this key indicator spells grouble for oil investors [120] => this key indicator spells yrouble for oil investors [121] => this key indicator spells 6rouble for oil investors [122] => this key indicator spells 5rouble for oil investors [123] => this key indicator spells teouble for oil investors [124] => this key indicator spells tdouble for oil investors [125] => this key indicator spells tfouble for oil investors [126] => this key indicator spells ttouble for oil investors [127] => this key indicator spells t5ouble for oil investors [128] => this key indicator spells t4ouble for oil investors [129] => this key indicator spells triuble for oil investors [130] => this key indicator spells trkuble for oil investors [131] => this key indicator spells trluble for oil investors [132] => this key indicator spells trpuble for oil investors [133] => this key indicator spells tr0uble for oil investors [134] => this key indicator spells tr9uble for oil investors [135] => this key indicator spells troyble for oil investors [136] => this key indicator spells trohble for oil investors [137] => this key indicator spells trojble for oil investors [138] => this key indicator spells troible for oil investors [139] => this key indicator spells tro8ble for oil investors [140] => this key indicator spells tro7ble for oil investors [141] => this key indicator spells trouvle for oil investors [142] => this key indicator spells trounle for oil investors [143] => this key indicator spells trouhle for oil investors [144] => this key indicator spells trougle for oil investors [145] => this key indicator spells troubke for oil investors [146] => this key indicator spells troubpe for oil investors [147] => this key indicator spells trouboe for oil investors [148] => this key indicator spells troublw for oil investors [149] => this key indicator spells troubls for oil investors [150] => this key indicator spells troubld for oil investors [151] => this key indicator spells troublr for oil investors [152] => this key indicator spells troubl4 for oil investors [153] => this key indicator spells troubl3 for oil investors [154] => this key indicator spells trouble dor oil investors [155] => this key indicator spells trouble cor oil investors [156] => this key indicator spells trouble vor oil investors [157] => this key indicator spells trouble gor oil investors [158] => this key indicator spells trouble tor oil investors [159] => this key indicator spells trouble ror oil investors [160] => this key indicator spells trouble fir oil investors [161] => this key indicator spells trouble fkr oil investors [162] => this key indicator spells trouble flr oil investors [163] => this key indicator spells trouble fpr oil investors [164] => this key indicator spells trouble f0r oil investors [165] => this key indicator spells trouble f9r oil investors [166] => this key indicator spells trouble foe oil investors [167] => this key indicator spells trouble fod oil investors [168] => this key indicator spells trouble fof oil investors [169] => this key indicator spells trouble fot oil investors [170] => this key indicator spells trouble fo5 oil investors [171] => this key indicator spells trouble fo4 oil investors [172] => this key indicator spells trouble for iil investors [173] => this key indicator spells trouble for kil investors [174] => this key indicator spells trouble for lil investors [175] => this key indicator spells trouble for pil investors [176] => this key indicator spells trouble for 0il investors [177] => this key indicator spells trouble for 9il investors [178] => this key indicator spells trouble for oul investors [179] => this key indicator spells trouble for ojl investors [180] => this key indicator spells trouble for okl investors [181] => this key indicator spells trouble for ool investors [182] => this key indicator spells trouble for o9l investors [183] => this key indicator spells trouble for o8l investors [184] => this key indicator spells trouble for oik investors [185] => this key indicator spells trouble for oip investors [186] => this key indicator spells trouble for oio investors [187] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil unvestors [188] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil jnvestors [189] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil knvestors [190] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil onvestors [191] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil 9nvestors [192] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil 8nvestors [193] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil ibvestors [194] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil imvestors [195] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil ijvestors [196] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil ihvestors [197] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil incestors [198] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil inbestors [199] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil ingestors [200] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil infestors [201] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invwstors [202] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invsstors [203] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invdstors [204] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invrstors [205] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil inv4stors [206] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil inv3stors [207] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil inveators [208] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil inveztors [209] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invextors [210] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invedtors [211] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil inveetors [212] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invewtors [213] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invesrors [214] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invesfors [215] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invesgors [216] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invesyors [217] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil inves6ors [218] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil inves5ors [219] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investirs [220] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investkrs [221] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investlrs [222] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investprs [223] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invest0rs [224] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil invest9rs [225] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investoes [226] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investods [227] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investofs [228] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investots [229] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investo5s [230] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investo4s [231] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investora [232] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investorz [233] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investorx [234] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investord [235] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investore [236] => this key indicator spells trouble for oil investorw ) </h1> </body>