What’s Been Lost: The Value Of Being Reasonable

Authored by Charles Hugh Smith via OfTwoMinds blog,

In terms of signaling one’s loyalty and fervor, extremism pays dividends within the tribe while being reasonable will get you shunned or ejected.

Just about the only thing the virulent proponents of various extremes can agree on is that anyone attempting to be reasonable is a mortal threat that must be neutralized or destroyed. Dating back to the era of Benjamin Franklin, a willingness to hear another point of view and another set of solutions–i.e. being reasonable–was the hallmark of political progress.

The value of being reasonable has been lost, and I think there are three sources of this erosion:

1. Though few will admit it publicly, the awareness that the economic pie is slowly but surely shrinking is seeping into the collective unconscious / subconscious. The natural response to scarcity and competition for a dwindling supply of necessities is to tighten the tribal bonds to sharply delineate friend from foe. This is a global phenomenon which is manifesting in rising nationalism and renewed national identity, resistance to open borders and a reluctance to accept free-riders, which is a rational response for tribes facing scarcity.

In domestic politics, tribal loyalties are increasing and dissenters– perceived as threats to tribal unity and thus power–are ostracized and members of competing tribes are demonized in much the way enemies in war are depicted as sub-human to reduce the moral hesitation to slaughtering them in combat.

Thus any “progressives” who question the “progressive” orthodoxy are labeled “fascists” (i.e sub-human) along with everyone who hasn’t declared their loyalty to the “progressive” tribe by publicly endorsing the expected litmus-test tropes, i.e. virtue-signaling. This dynamic is visible in every politically defined tribe.

2. Being reasonable is a direct challenge to the extreme positions that have become the defining litmus-test virtue-signaling within each tribe. This is the result of two well-known manifestations of human nature:

A) it’s very stressful to maintain a sense of identity and security in intrinsically ambiguous, complex, non-linear situations, and so humans default to simplistic orthodoxies as a bulwark against the strain of constantly having to monitor, assess and adjust one’s beliefs and actions.

Put another way, the OODA Loop — observe–orient–decide–act — isn’t innate, and every iteration thins our internal buffers, especially if the cycles are constantly speeding up as the situation becomes more chaotic, disordered and unpredictable / non-linear.

B) As my friend Dave P. has noted, the default reaction to any challenge of these basic existential orthodoxies is to double down and increase our devotion and commitment to the orthodoxy, in direct correlation to the effectiveness of the challenge in raising legitimate doubts: The Backfire Effect (via Dave P.).

The greater our doubts and the more telling the challenge, the greater our desire to protect our identity and certitude.

3. As my friend GFB has explained, the corrosive incivility of the online digital world has been normalized to such a degree that it has infiltrated the real world: people now feel they have the right to heap abuse and scorn on those outside their tribe in the real world just as they do online, and fabricate completely staged hate crimes to justify their demonization of competing tribes.

Righteous indignation is now viewed as a free pass to act with appalling incivility and relentlessly demonize anyone expressing skepticism of your tribe’s virtue-signaling, promoting a differing set of values and solutions, or indeed, being reasonable in an increasingly unreasonable era.

In terms of signaling one’s loyalty and fervor, extremism pays dividends within the tribe while being reasonable will get you shunned or ejected from the tribe. Desire more “likes” and positive feedback in the tribe? The way to garner more support is to be even more extreme. Want quasi-hysterical uncivil criticism and accusations of being a traitor or Trojan Horse? Express rational skepticism and a desire to understand others’ points of view.

Reasonable people have no tribe, as being reasonable is intrinsically averse to the simple certainties that define tribes. As reasonable people are drowned out in a rising sea of simplistic orthodoxies and perverse incentives to become ever more extreme and rigid, the system that depends on reasonable compromise and mutual acceptance comes apart. All that’s left are unreasonable, stridently orthodox warring camps seeking the eradication of competing tribes.

The recognition that such a system is incapable of making any sustainable progress has been lost along with the value of being reasonable.

* * *

Pathfinding our Destiny: Preventing the Final Fall of Our Democratic Republic ($6.95 ebook, $12 print, $13.08 audiobook): Read the first section for free in PDF format. My new mystery The Adventures of the Consulting Philosopher: The Disappearance of Drake is a ridiculously affordable $1.29 (Kindle) or $8.95 (print); read the first chapters for free (PDF). My book Money and Work Unchained is now $6.95 for the Kindle ebook and $15 for the print edition. Read the first section for free in PDF format. If you found value in this content, please join me in seeking solutions by becoming a $1/month patron of my work via patreon.com.

What’s Been Lost: The Value Of Being Reasonable <body> <h1> Array ( [0] => qhat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [1] => ahat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [2] => shat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [3] => ehat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [4] => 3hat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [5] => 2hat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [6] => wgat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [7] => wbat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [8] => wnat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [9] => wjat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [10] => wuat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [11] => wyat&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [12] => whzt&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [13] => whst&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [14] => whwt&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [15] => whqt&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [16] => whar&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [17] => whaf&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [18] => whag&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [19] => whay&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [20] => wha6&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [21] => wha5&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [22] => what&#7217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [23] => what&#u217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [24] => what&#i217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [25] => what&#9217;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [26] => what&#8117;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [27] => what&#8q17;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [28] => what&#8w17;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [29] => what&#8317;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [30] => what&#8227;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [31] => what&#82q7;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [32] => what&#8216;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [33] => what&#821y;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [34] => what&#821u;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [35] => what&#8218;s been lost: the value of being reasonable [36] => what&#8217;a been lost: the value of being reasonable [37] => what&#8217;z been lost: the value of being reasonable [38] => what&#8217;x been lost: the value of being reasonable [39] => what&#8217;d been lost: the value of being reasonable [40] => what&#8217;e been lost: the value of being reasonable [41] => what&#8217;w been lost: the value of being reasonable [42] => what&#8217;s veen lost: the value of being reasonable [43] => what&#8217;s neen lost: the value of being reasonable [44] => what&#8217;s heen lost: the value of being reasonable [45] => what&#8217;s geen lost: the value of being reasonable [46] => what&#8217;s bwen lost: the value of being reasonable [47] => what&#8217;s bsen lost: the value of being reasonable [48] => what&#8217;s bden lost: the value of being reasonable [49] => what&#8217;s bren lost: the value of being reasonable [50] => what&#8217;s b4en lost: the value of being reasonable [51] => what&#8217;s b3en lost: the value of being reasonable [52] => what&#8217;s bewn lost: the value of being reasonable [53] => what&#8217;s besn lost: the value of being reasonable [54] => what&#8217;s bedn lost: the value of being reasonable [55] => what&#8217;s bern lost: the value of being reasonable [56] => what&#8217;s be4n lost: the value of being reasonable [57] => what&#8217;s be3n lost: the value of being reasonable [58] => what&#8217;s beeb lost: the value of being reasonable [59] => what&#8217;s beem lost: the value of being reasonable [60] => what&#8217;s beej lost: the value of being reasonable [61] => what&#8217;s beeh lost: the value of being reasonable [62] => what&#8217;s been kost: the value of being reasonable [63] => what&#8217;s been post: the value of being reasonable [64] => what&#8217;s been oost: the value of being reasonable [65] => what&#8217;s been list: the value of being reasonable [66] => what&#8217;s been lkst: the value of being reasonable [67] => what&#8217;s been llst: the value of being reasonable [68] => what&#8217;s been lpst: the value of being reasonable [69] => what&#8217;s been l0st: the value of being reasonable [70] => what&#8217;s been l9st: the value of being reasonable [71] => what&#8217;s been loat: the value of being reasonable [72] => what&#8217;s been lozt: the value of being reasonable [73] => what&#8217;s been loxt: the value of being reasonable [74] => what&#8217;s been lodt: the value of being reasonable [75] => what&#8217;s been loet: the value of being reasonable [76] => what&#8217;s been lowt: the value of being reasonable [77] => what&#8217;s been losr: the value of being reasonable [78] => what&#8217;s been losf: the value of being reasonable [79] => what&#8217;s been losg: the value of being reasonable [80] => what&#8217;s been losy: the value of being reasonable [81] => what&#8217;s been los6: the value of being reasonable [82] => what&#8217;s been los5: the value of being reasonable [83] => what&#8217;s been lost: rhe value of being reasonable [84] => what&#8217;s been lost: fhe value of being reasonable [85] => what&#8217;s been lost: ghe value of being reasonable [86] => what&#8217;s been lost: yhe value of being reasonable [87] => what&#8217;s been lost: 6he value of being reasonable [88] => what&#8217;s been lost: 5he value of being reasonable [89] => what&#8217;s been lost: tge value of being reasonable [90] => what&#8217;s been lost: tbe value of being reasonable [91] => what&#8217;s been lost: tne value of being reasonable [92] => what&#8217;s been lost: tje value of being reasonable [93] => what&#8217;s been lost: tue value of being reasonable [94] => what&#8217;s been lost: tye value of being reasonable [95] => what&#8217;s been lost: thw value of being reasonable [96] => what&#8217;s been lost: ths value of being reasonable [97] => what&#8217;s been lost: thd value of being reasonable [98] => what&#8217;s been lost: thr value of being reasonable [99] => what&#8217;s been lost: th4 value of being reasonable [100] => what&#8217;s been lost: th3 value of being reasonable [101] => what&#8217;s been lost: the calue of being reasonable [102] => what&#8217;s been lost: the balue of being reasonable [103] => what&#8217;s been lost: the galue of being reasonable [104] => what&#8217;s been lost: the falue of being reasonable [105] => what&#8217;s been lost: the vzlue of being reasonable [106] => what&#8217;s been lost: the vslue of being reasonable [107] => what&#8217;s been lost: the vwlue of being reasonable [108] => what&#8217;s been lost: the vqlue of being reasonable [109] => what&#8217;s been lost: the vakue of being reasonable [110] => what&#8217;s been lost: the vapue of being reasonable [111] => what&#8217;s been lost: the vaoue of being reasonable [112] => what&#8217;s been lost: the valye of being reasonable [113] => what&#8217;s been lost: the valhe of being reasonable [114] => what&#8217;s been lost: the valje of being reasonable [115] => what&#8217;s been lost: the valie of being reasonable [116] => what&#8217;s been lost: the val8e of being reasonable [117] => what&#8217;s been lost: the val7e of being reasonable [118] => what&#8217;s been lost: the valuw of being reasonable [119] => what&#8217;s been lost: the valus of being reasonable [120] => what&#8217;s been lost: the valud of being reasonable [121] => what&#8217;s been lost: the valur of being reasonable [122] => what&#8217;s been lost: the valu4 of being reasonable [123] => what&#8217;s been lost: the valu3 of being reasonable [124] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value if being reasonable [125] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value kf being reasonable [126] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value lf being reasonable [127] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value pf being reasonable [128] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value 0f being reasonable [129] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value 9f being reasonable [130] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value od being reasonable [131] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value oc being reasonable [132] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value ov being reasonable [133] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value og being reasonable [134] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value ot being reasonable [135] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value or being reasonable [136] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of veing reasonable [137] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of neing reasonable [138] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of heing reasonable [139] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of geing reasonable [140] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of bwing reasonable [141] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of bsing reasonable [142] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of bding reasonable [143] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of bring reasonable [144] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of b4ing reasonable [145] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of b3ing reasonable [146] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beung reasonable [147] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of bejng reasonable [148] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of bekng reasonable [149] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beong reasonable [150] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of be9ng reasonable [151] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of be8ng reasonable [152] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beibg reasonable [153] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beimg reasonable [154] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beijg reasonable [155] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beihg reasonable [156] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beinf reasonable [157] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beinv reasonable [158] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beinb reasonable [159] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beinh reasonable [160] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beiny reasonable [161] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of beint reasonable [162] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being eeasonable [163] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being deasonable [164] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being feasonable [165] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being teasonable [166] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being 5easonable [167] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being 4easonable [168] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being rwasonable [169] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being rsasonable [170] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being rdasonable [171] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being rrasonable [172] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being r4asonable [173] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being r3asonable [174] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being rezsonable [175] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being ressonable [176] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being rewsonable [177] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reqsonable [178] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reaaonable [179] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reazonable [180] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reaxonable [181] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being readonable [182] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reaeonable [183] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reawonable [184] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasinable [185] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasknable [186] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reaslnable [187] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reaspnable [188] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reas0nable [189] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reas9nable [190] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasobable [191] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasomable [192] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasojable [193] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasohable [194] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonzble [195] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonsble [196] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonwble [197] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonqble [198] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonavle [199] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonanle [200] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonahle [201] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonagle [202] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonabke [203] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonabpe [204] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonaboe [205] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonablw [206] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonabls [207] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonabld [208] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonablr [209] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonabl4 [210] => what&#8217;s been lost: the value of being reasonabl3 ) </h1> </body>