Xi Jinping Thinks China Is World’s Only Sovereign State

Authored by Gordon Chang via The Gatestone Institute,

  • The trend of Chinese ruler Xi Jinping’s recent comments warns us that his China does not want to live within the current Westphalian system of nation states or even to adjust it. From every indication, Xi is thinking of overthrowing it altogether.

  • Beijing now thinks it can, with impunity, injure Americans. In the first week of May, the Pentagon said that China, from its base in Djibouti, lasered a C-130 military cargo plane, causing eye injuries to two American pilots.

  • The laser attack in the Horn of Africa, far from any Chinese boundaries, highlights Beijing’s unstated position that the U.S. military has no right to operate anywhere and that China is free to do whatever it wants anyplace it chooses. And let us understand the severity of the Chinese act: an attempt to blind pilots is akin to an attempt to bring down their planes, and an attempt to bring down planes is an assertion China has the right to kill.

The trend of Chinese ruler Xi Jinping’s recent comments warns us that his China does not want to live within the current Westphalian system or even to adjust it. From every indication, Xi is thinking of overthrowing it altogether. Pictured: Xi Jinping (center) at a Chinese Communist Party event on January 2, 2019 in Beijing. (Photo by Mark Schiefelbein-Pool/Getty Images)

“I hear prominent Americans, disappointed that China has not become a democracy, claiming that China poses a threat to the American way of life,” Jimmy Carter wrote on the last day of 2018 in a Washington Post op-ed.

That claim, Carter tells us, is a “dangerous notion.”

There is nothing more dangerous than a notion from the 39th president, even on China. China, despite what he said, threatens not only America’s way of life but also the existence of the American republic. Chinese ruler Xi Jinping has, in recent years, been making the extraordinary case that the U.S. is not a sovereign state.

The breathtaking position puts China’s aggressive actions into a far more ominous context.

Carter, and almost all others who comment on Chinese foreign policy, see Beijing competing for influence in the current international order. That existing order, accepted virtually everywhere, is based on the Treaty of Westphalia of 1648, which recognizes the sovereignty of individual states that are supposed to refrain from interfering in each other’s internal affairs. Those states now compete and cooperate in a framework, largely developed after World War II, of treaties, conventions, covenants, and norms.

Many Chinese policymakers believe they are entitled to dominate others, especially peoples on their periphery. That concept underpinned the imperial tributary system in which states near and far were supposed to acknowledge Chinese rule. Although there is no “cultural DNA” that forces today’s communist leaders to view the world as emperors did long ago, the tributary system nonetheless presents, as Stephen Platt of the University of Massachusetts points out, “a tempting model” of “a nostalgic ‘half-idealized, half-mythologized past.’ “

In that past, there were no fixed national boundaries. There was even no concept of “China.” There was, as Yi-Zheng Lian wrote in the New York Times, “a sovereignty system with the emperor’s compound in the middle.” Around that were concentric rings. “The further from the center, the less the center’s control and one’s obligations to it,” Lian noted. The Chinese, in fact, were perhaps the first to develop the idea of a borderless world.

In short, Chinese emperors claimed they had the Mandate of Heaven over tianxia, or “All Under Heaven,” as they believed they were, in the words of Fei-Ling Wang of Georgia Tech, “predestined and compelled to order and rule the entire world that is known and reachable, in reality or in pretension.” As acclaimed journalist Howard French writes in Everything Under the Heavens, “One can argue that there has never been a more universal conception of rule.”

Unfortunately, the current Chinese leader harbors ambitions of imposing the tianxia model on others. As Charles Horner of the Hudson Institute told me, “The Communist Party of China remains committed to ordering the People’s Republic of China as a one-party dictatorship, and that is perforce its starting point for thinking about ordering the world.” In other words, a dictatorial state naturally thinks about the world in dictatorial terms. Tianxia is by its nature a top-down, dictatorial system.

Xi Jinping has employed tianxia language for more than a decade, but recently his references have become unmistakable. “The Chinese have always held that the world is united and all under heaven are one family,” he declared in his 2017 New Year’s Message. He recycled tianxia themes in his 2018 New Year’s message and hinted at them in his most recent one as well.

Xi has also used Chinese officials to explain the breathtaking scope of his revolutionary message. Foreign Minister Wang Yi, in Study Times, the Central Party School newspaper, in September 2017 wrote that Xi Jinping’s “thought on diplomacy”—a “thought” in Communist Party lingo is an important body of ideological work—”has made innovations on and transcended the traditional Western theories of international relations for the past 300 years.” Wang with his time reference is almost certainly pointing to the Westphalian system of sovereign states. His use of “transcended,” consequently, hints that Xi wants a world without sovereign states—or at least no more of them than China.

The trend of Xi’s recent comments warns us that his China does not want to live within the current Westphalian system or even to adjust it. From every indication, Xi is thinking of overthrowing it altogether, trying to replace Westphalia’s cacophony with tianxia‘s orderliness.

Xi not only spouts tianxia-like statements, his regime also employs scholars to study the application of tianxia to the world.

He also acts tianxia. His China in December 2016 seized a U.S. Navy drone in international water in the South China Sea. Chinese spokesman Yang Yujun said, according to the official Xinhua News Agency, that one of its navy’s lifeboats “located an unidentified device” and retrieved it “to prevent the device from causing harm to the safety of navigation and personnel of passing vessels.”

In fact, China’s ships had over a long period tailed the USNS Bowditch, an unarmed U.S. Navy reconnaissance vessel. The American crew, who at the time were trying to retrieve the drone, repeatedly radioed the Chinese sailors, who ignored their calls and, within 500 yards of the U.S. craft, went into the water in a small boat to seize it. The Chinese by radio told the Bowditch they were keeping the drone.

The site of the seizure, about 50 nautical miles northwest of Subic Bay, was so close to the shoreline of the Philippines that it was beyond China’s expansive “nine-dash line” claim. There was absolutely no justification for the Chinese navy to grab the drone. The intentional taking of what the Defense Department termed a “sovereign immune vessel” of the United States showed that Beijing thought it was not bound by any rules of conduct.

Beijing now thinks it can, with impunity, injure Americans. In the first week of May, the Pentagon said that China, from its base in Djibouti, lasered a C-130 military cargo plane, causing eye injuries to two American pilots.

The laser attack in the Horn of Africa, far from any Chinese boundaries, highlights Beijing’s unstated position that the U.S. military has no right to operate anywhere and that China is free to do whatever it wants anyplace it chooses. And let us understand the severity of the Chinese act: an attempt to blind pilots is akin to an attempt to bring down their planes and an attempt to bring down planes is an assertion China has the right to kill.

China has been called a “trivial state,” one which seeks nothing more than “perpetuation of the regime itself and the protection of the county’s territorial integrity.” This view fundamentally underestimates the nature of the Chinese challenge. China, under Xi Jinping, has become a revolutionary regime that seeks not only to dominate others but also take away their sovereignty.

Xi at this moment cannot compel others to accept his audacious vision of a China-centric world, but he has put the world on notice.

These events together mean, once again, that Carter has failed to understand a hardline regime. In his op-ed, he warns America against starting “a modern Cold War” with China. Washington, in reality, cannot start anything. There already is a struggle that Xi Jinping has made existential.

Xi Jinping Thinks China Is World’s Only Sovereign State <body> <h1> Array ( [0] => zi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [1] => ci jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [2] => di jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [3] => si jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [4] => xu jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [5] => xj jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [6] => xk jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [7] => xo jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [8] => x9 jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [9] => x8 jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [10] => xi hinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [11] => xi ninping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [12] => xi minping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [13] => xi kinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [14] => xi iinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [15] => xi uinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [16] => xi junping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [17] => xi jjnping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [18] => xi jknping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [19] => xi jonping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [20] => xi j9nping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [21] => xi j8nping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [22] => xi jibping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [23] => xi jimping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [24] => xi jijping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [25] => xi jihping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [26] => xi jinoing thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [27] => xi jinling thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [28] => xi jin-ing thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [29] => xi jin0ing thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [30] => xi jinpung thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [31] => xi jinpjng thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [32] => xi jinpkng thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [33] => xi jinpong thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [34] => xi jinp9ng thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [35] => xi jinp8ng thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [36] => xi jinpibg thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [37] => xi jinpimg thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [38] => xi jinpijg thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [39] => xi jinpihg thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [40] => xi jinpinf thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [41] => xi jinpinv thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [42] => xi jinpinb thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [43] => xi jinpinh thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [44] => xi jinpiny thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [45] => xi jinpint thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [46] => xi jinping rhinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [47] => xi jinping fhinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [48] => xi jinping ghinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [49] => xi jinping yhinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [50] => xi jinping 6hinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [51] => xi jinping 5hinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [52] => xi jinping tginks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [53] => xi jinping tbinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [54] => xi jinping tninks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [55] => xi jinping tjinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [56] => xi jinping tuinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [57] => xi jinping tyinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [58] => xi jinping thunks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [59] => xi jinping thjnks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [60] => xi jinping thknks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [61] => xi jinping thonks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [62] => xi jinping th9nks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [63] => xi jinping th8nks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [64] => xi jinping thibks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [65] => xi jinping thimks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [66] => xi jinping thijks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [67] => xi jinping thihks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [68] => xi jinping thinjs china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [69] => xi jinping thinms china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [70] => xi jinping thinls china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [71] => xi jinping thinos china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [72] => xi jinping thinis china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [73] => xi jinping thinka china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [74] => xi jinping thinkz china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [75] => xi jinping thinkx china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [76] => xi jinping thinkd china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [77] => xi jinping thinke china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [78] => xi jinping thinkw china is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [79] => xi jinping thinks xhina is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [80] => xi jinping thinks vhina is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [81] => xi jinping thinks fhina is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [82] => xi jinping thinks dhina is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [83] => xi jinping thinks cgina is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [84] => xi jinping thinks cbina is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [85] => xi jinping thinks cnina is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [86] => xi jinping thinks cjina is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [87] => xi jinping thinks cuina is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [88] => xi jinping thinks cyina is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [89] => xi jinping thinks chuna is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [90] => xi jinping thinks chjna is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [91] => xi jinping thinks chkna is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [92] => xi jinping thinks chona is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [93] => xi jinping thinks ch9na is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [94] => xi jinping thinks ch8na is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [95] => xi jinping thinks chiba is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [96] => xi jinping thinks chima is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [97] => xi jinping thinks chija is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [98] => xi jinping thinks chiha is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [99] => xi jinping thinks chinz is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [100] => xi jinping thinks chins is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [101] => xi jinping thinks chinw is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [102] => xi jinping thinks chinq is world&#8217;s only sovereign state [103] => xi jinping thinks china us world&#8217;s only sovereign state [104] => xi jinping thinks china js world&#8217;s only sovereign state [105] => xi jinping thinks china ks world&#8217;s only sovereign state [106] => xi jinping thinks china os world&#8217;s only sovereign state [107] => xi jinping thinks china 9s world&#8217;s only sovereign state [108] => xi jinping thinks china 8s world&#8217;s only sovereign state [109] => xi jinping thinks china ia world&#8217;s only sovereign state [110] => xi jinping thinks china iz world&#8217;s only sovereign state [111] => xi jinping thinks china ix world&#8217;s only sovereign state [112] => xi jinping thinks china id world&#8217;s only sovereign state [113] => xi jinping thinks china ie world&#8217;s only sovereign state [114] => xi jinping thinks china iw world&#8217;s only sovereign state [115] => xi jinping thinks china is qorld&#8217;s only sovereign state [116] => xi jinping thinks china is aorld&#8217;s only sovereign state [117] => xi jinping thinks china is sorld&#8217;s only sovereign state [118] => xi jinping thinks china is eorld&#8217;s only sovereign state [119] => xi jinping thinks china is 3orld&#8217;s only sovereign state [120] => xi jinping thinks china is 2orld&#8217;s only sovereign state [121] => xi jinping thinks china is wirld&#8217;s only sovereign state [122] => xi jinping thinks china is wkrld&#8217;s only sovereign state [123] => xi jinping thinks china is wlrld&#8217;s only sovereign state [124] => xi jinping thinks china is wprld&#8217;s only sovereign state [125] => xi jinping thinks china is w0rld&#8217;s only sovereign state [126] => xi jinping thinks china is w9rld&#8217;s only sovereign state [127] => xi jinping thinks china is woeld&#8217;s only sovereign state [128] => xi jinping thinks china is wodld&#8217;s only sovereign state [129] => xi jinping thinks china is wofld&#8217;s only sovereign state [130] => xi jinping thinks china is wotld&#8217;s only sovereign state [131] => xi jinping thinks china is wo5ld&#8217;s only sovereign state [132] => xi jinping thinks china is wo4ld&#8217;s only sovereign state [133] => xi jinping thinks china is workd&#8217;s only sovereign state [134] => xi jinping thinks china is worpd&#8217;s only sovereign state [135] => xi jinping thinks china is worod&#8217;s only sovereign state [136] => xi jinping thinks china is worls&#8217;s only sovereign state [137] => xi jinping thinks china is worlx&#8217;s only sovereign state [138] => xi jinping thinks china is worlc&#8217;s only sovereign state [139] => xi jinping thinks china is worlf&#8217;s only sovereign state [140] => xi jinping thinks china is worlr&#8217;s only sovereign state [141] => xi jinping thinks china is worle&#8217;s only sovereign state [142] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#7217;s only sovereign state [143] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#u217;s only sovereign state [144] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#i217;s only sovereign state [145] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#9217;s only sovereign state [146] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8117;s only sovereign state [147] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8q17;s only sovereign state [148] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8w17;s only sovereign state [149] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8317;s only sovereign state [150] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8227;s only sovereign state [151] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#82q7;s only sovereign state [152] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8216;s only sovereign state [153] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#821y;s only sovereign state [154] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#821u;s only sovereign state [155] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8218;s only sovereign state [156] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;a only sovereign state [157] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;z only sovereign state [158] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;x only sovereign state [159] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;d only sovereign state [160] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;e only sovereign state [161] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;w only sovereign state [162] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s inly sovereign state [163] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s knly sovereign state [164] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s lnly sovereign state [165] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s pnly sovereign state [166] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s 0nly sovereign state [167] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s 9nly sovereign state [168] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s obly sovereign state [169] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s omly sovereign state [170] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s ojly sovereign state [171] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s ohly sovereign state [172] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s onky sovereign state [173] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s onpy sovereign state [174] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s onoy sovereign state [175] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s onlt sovereign state [176] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s onlg sovereign state [177] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s onlh sovereign state [178] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s onlu sovereign state [179] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s onl7 sovereign state [180] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s onl6 sovereign state [181] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only aovereign state [182] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only zovereign state [183] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only xovereign state [184] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only dovereign state [185] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only eovereign state [186] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only wovereign state [187] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sivereign state [188] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only skvereign state [189] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only slvereign state [190] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only spvereign state [191] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only s0vereign state [192] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only s9vereign state [193] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only socereign state [194] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sobereign state [195] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sogereign state [196] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sofereign state [197] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovwreign state [198] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovsreign state [199] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovdreign state [200] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovrreign state [201] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sov4reign state [202] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sov3reign state [203] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only soveeeign state [204] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovedeign state [205] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovefeign state [206] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only soveteign state [207] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sove5eign state [208] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sove4eign state [209] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only soverwign state [210] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only soversign state [211] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only soverdign state [212] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only soverrign state [213] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sover4ign state [214] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sover3ign state [215] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereugn state [216] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only soverejgn state [217] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only soverekgn state [218] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereogn state [219] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovere9gn state [220] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovere8gn state [221] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereifn state [222] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereivn state [223] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereibn state [224] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereihn state [225] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereiyn state [226] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereitn state [227] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereigb state [228] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereigm state [229] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereigj state [230] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereigh state [231] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign atate [232] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign ztate [233] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign xtate [234] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign dtate [235] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign etate [236] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign wtate [237] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign srate [238] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign sfate [239] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign sgate [240] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign syate [241] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign s6ate [242] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign s5ate [243] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign stzte [244] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign stste [245] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign stwte [246] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign stqte [247] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign stare [248] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign stafe [249] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign stage [250] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign staye [251] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign sta6e [252] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign sta5e [253] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign statw [254] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign stats [255] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign statd [256] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign statr [257] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign stat4 [258] => xi jinping thinks china is world&#8217;s only sovereign stat3 ) </h1> </body>