DEAR MISS MANNERS: In a supermarket, I had a conversation with the family of a very noisy child, about 6 years old. I protested the noise, while Mom defended it vigorously.
Related Articles
Miss Manners: Should I tell them they gave me a knockoff of my signature scent?
Miss Manners: Everybody says I just need to find the right woman. I did. She died.
Miss Manners: Criticizing someone’s children can be a minefield. What do I do?
Miss Manners: Don’t tell me what to do. I know the rules.
Miss Manners: The women are having fun picking on the bride behind her back
I walked away and continued my shopping. A few minutes later, the store manager stopped by to tell me that “disrespecting children” was against store policy and would not be tolerated. She referred me to the company website, but of course, I could find no such policy statement.
Why must members of the public be disrespected by unruly, misbehaving, noisy children, who are then defended by adults who should know better?
I am not a fan of authoritarian or permissive parenting, and believe in the principle of a community of equal dignity. Sometimes, a parent should address the noisy behavior of a child rather than ignore it — especially in a public place, where it can affect and upset other people. As in this case.
What is your view on this?
GENTLE READER: That indeed, a parent must sometimes deal with a disruptive child in public. It’s not easy or fun, but Miss Manners dares say that every parent has to go through it.
But why did you? Unlike the parent, you were in the enviable position of being able to move to another aisle, away from the noise. Why didn’t you?
DEAR MISS MANNERS: I had cancer last year and lost my hair. I’m fine now, but my hair is growing back super curly. Every day, people make comments about it: “Oh, your hair! It’s so curly!”
It’s a painful reminder when I’m trying to feel normal again. I’ve tried explaining that I’m upset about my looks and don’t like to be reminded, but then they argue that it looks good.
Every woman at church brings it up, not realizing it’s hard for me to hear dozens of these comments. One woman at the gym commented loudly every day, even after I asked her to stop. I finally burst into tears.
It will take two years for my hair to be long and feminine again. Any ideas on how to stop the comments in the meantime?
GENTLE READER: Unfortunately, there is no legal way to stop foolish people from informing others how they look.
Related Articles
Asking Eric: He’s tired of doing all the chores while she sits around gaming
Miss Manners: Should I tell them they gave me a knockoff of my signature scent?
Asking Eric: I wish I didn’t have to hear this mockery of my parents
Asking Eric: I didn’t hear from any of my family on my birthday and I’m hurt
Miss Manners: Everybody says I just need to find the right woman. I did. She died.
They seem to think it useful to point out to tall people that they are tall, to the short that they are short, and so on. Fat, thin — anything noticeable. And if they are challenged, they claim to be giving compliments.
Even your tears have probably not prompted the offender at the gym to realize that she had erred. Rather, she likely thought that you were just oversensitive (a counter-charge often lobbed by rude people). It is a wonder she didn’t announce that.
So Miss Manners can offer little hope that you can retrain those who are determined to comment on appearances. Sorry. She can only caution you not to respond. A silent, humorless stare should at least stop them from elaborating on their remarks.
Please send your questions to Miss Manners at her website, www.missmanners.com; to her email, gentlereader@missmanners.com; or through postal mail to Miss Manners, Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106.
https://www.sun-sentinel.com/2025/12/01/miss-manners-noisy-child-in-store/
